Sunday, May 30, 2010

Dorothea Heitsch: "Renaissance Soul-Searching"

Dorothea Heitsch
University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill

Renaissance Soul-Searching (1555-1584):
Maurice Scève, Jacques Peletier du Mans, Pierre de Ronsard, Guillaume Du Bartas, René Bretonnayau


"Aristippus ne defendoit que le corps, comme si nous n’avions pas d’ame; Zenon n’embrassoit que l’ame, comme si nous n’avions pas de corps. Tous deux vicieusement."[1]

1> In the following pages, I analyze some aspects of the body-soul relationship in a choice of pre-Cartesian texts.[2] All texts were written in the second half of the sixteenth century by French writers who endeavored to develop a discourse of natural philosophy in the tradition of Lucretian poetry. These Renaissance poets lived in a world in which university scholarship proposed an Aristotelian doctrine of three souls (vegetative, sentient, rational) and where the revived Platonic and Neo-Platonic doctrines of the soul which were considered incompatible with Aristotle’s were thought quite concordant with the Christian understanding of the immortal soul by many. Controversy arose over certain Neo-Platonic views such as metempsychosis which some considered heretical. Another controversy emerged over whether the rational soul and the Christian immortal soul were identical or not, giving rise to Averroistic objections and the Pomponazzi affair: Pomponazzi had maintained that according to Aristotle and according to reason the soul was not immortal; this prompted the Lateran Council of 1513, in whose wake Pomponazzi had De immortalitate animae published in 1516. Other discussions concerning the nature of the soul then were to follow in print. It is into this map of soul-searching that I insert my Renaissance authors.[3]

2> One way of approaching the relationship between body and soul is through the “topos” of the flight of the soul, a literary commonplace reaching back to, among numerous texts, Plato’s Phaidros as well as to his Phaidon where Socrates presents the otherworld, to Cicero’s Dream of Scipio, and, in a sense, to Dante’s Paradiso: by means of the flight, the soul is set free of its corporeal prison. All four texts discuss metempsychosis as a journey to the beyond from where the soul (of the poet) returns in order to relate what it has seen and learnt. In the Amour des amours (1555), the French writer Jacques Peletier du Mans, who is known for enriching the French language in order to give it its modern form, takes up this image. Similarly, the body-soul problem can be found in Pierre de Ronsard’s poetry, as for example in the hymns (1555, 1556) and the enigmatic text entitled Le chat (1569), in Maurice Scève’s Microcosme (1562), in René Bretonnayau’s La génération de l’homme et le temple de l’âme (1583), and in Guillaume Du Bartas’s Sepmaine (1578, 1584). These French texts belong to the so-called scientific poetry that was defined by Albert-Marie Schmidt.[4] Beverly Ridgely has narrowed down the scope of texts for my purposes.[5] In her all-encompassing analysis, Isabelle Pantin has determined that in the sixteenth century the gap between poetic discourse and the astronomers’ findings is wide and that French poets still express a unitary cultural view where cosmology is not separated from theology and morality.[6] My own discussion begins here.[7]

3> Although the five poets do not directly work together, they all approach an apparently pressing problem from different angles. I am not discussing their poems as artistic, linguistic, and rhetorical constructs, because this has been done, in particular with regard to Ronsard.[8] Instead, for each of the chosen poets, two of my objectives are to ascertain whether they consider the body as a prison of the soul and whether they embrace death as a desired separation of soul and body. Other points of discussion are the soul as the center of a person and how to define the visible and the eternal, thus leading to the question of the immortality of the (individual) soul. In each case, I end my analysis by describing perception, memory, and the will as they are seen in the texts of my choice and by situating the poems in Renaissance discussions concerning Platonic, Neo-Platonic, Aristotelian, and theological doctrines of the soul. In this way, I determine the relationship between faith and “experientia,”[9] so that my investigation returns to the history of theology and philosophy of which it is a part, a fact that has been neglected by contemporary historians of these fields.[10]

An Infinite Mind: Maurice Scève’s “Microcosme” (1562)[11]


4> At the end of his life, the poet Maurice Scève from Lyon, who draws from both Late Medieval and Renaissance aesthetics, takes up the theme of the cosmic journey, but does not fully develop it in his anti-Lucretian Microcosme (1562). Like Cicero in the Somnium Scipionis, he visualizes it in the manner of a dream. It is in the third book of the Microcosme that Adam tells Eve his prophetic vision concerning the future of the world: “...puis luy recite en somme/ Le futur bien du Monde, et quel deviendra l’Homme”[12] (“...then summarizes for her/ The future good of the World/ and what will become of Man”). In this vision, the poet maps out the possibilities of humankind that are grounded in the “dignitas hominis” and in redemption, the two bases for intellectual and scientific achievement. Intelligence and human science are valorized by Scève, who at the same time warns his readers twice against the ambiguous use to which they can be put.[13] Consequently, Adam’s dream describes a movement toward redemption through what could be called scientific progress that is, however, based on a traditional worldview gleaned from the “septem artes liberales” and from sources such as the Bible, Gregor Reisch’s Margarita philosophica, Charles de Bovelles, Pico della Mirandola’s De Hominis Dignitate, and Nicolas of Cusa.

5> Scève’s Adam is a marvelous astronomer:

“Adam son dire alors accompaignoit de traits,
Et orbes enlacés diversement pourtraits
Par diametre, cercle, et ligne oblique, ou droitte,
Selon la longitude, et latitude estroitte,
Ou bien amplement large, et de tel art tracee.
Au point de son degré justement compassee,
Qu’en traçant il sembloit, que les Cieux, et leurs cours
Tournoyaient à sa main, et suyvaient son discours.” (3, v.169-76)

“Adam then accompanied his discourse with lines,
With intertwined orbs diversely drawn
By diameter, circle, oblique or straight line,
According to longitude and the right latitude,
Or wide enough and traced with art.
Surrounded justly at the point of its degree,
So that by tracing it, it seemed as if the Heavens and their course
Were turning at his hand, following his discourse.”

Not only that but he arranges the celestial bodies as if the heavens were turning at a sweep of his hand, aligning themselves according to his words. A little later, the poet says: “Icy tairay passant tous les arts sedentaires,/ Aucuns necessiteux, et autres voulentaires,/ [...] Que nostre Homme inventa...” (3, v.711-22; “Here will I pass over the sedentary arts, some necessary, some voluntary, [...] that our Man invented...”). As a microcosm, Adam creates his own world by imitating the divine act on a small scale. While Scève presents Adam’s revelations in a dream, that is, an intermediary that links the immaterial soul and the material body between which there cannot be a direct tie, according to theories inherited from Dante and the “dolce stil novo,” Adam becomes Eve’s teacher in the third book, thus illustrating the abilities of the human mind. The poet defines the human soul as follows:

“Que [le grand Ouvrier] de son saint Esprit luy soufla en la face
Une alaine de vie, une ame vegetante
Croissant de sensitive en ratiocinante,
Qui firent ce corps vif bouger, mouvoir, courir,
Et apte en tout, par tout, et de tout discourir.” (1, v.128-32)[14]

“That [God] breathed of his Holy Ghost into his face
A force of life, a vegetative soul
Growing from sentient to rational,
That made this living body stir, move, run,
And fit to speak in all, through all, and of all.”

6> An Aristotelian model of the tripartite soul as vegetative, sentient/animal, and rational in its three functions that Scève expresses through the plural “firent” is here combined with the Neo-Platonic concept of the soul as amphibian: the notion of “discourir,” which is provoked by the soul, reveals this faculty as an interpreter that, once it is incarnated in a body, can remain in the “Nous”/origin and can turn toward that which has become. The soul works at the seam between “Nous” and “materia,” the divisible and indivisible. It is eventually united with the world soul and therefore kin to the cosmos, which is one of the reasons that man has so much knowledge at his disposal in book three of the poem. In this way, Adam, “Ce Microcosme vif en sa pure innocence,/ Pure simplicité, sans art et sans science” (1, v.147; “This living Microcosm in its pure innocence,/ pure simplicity, without art and knowledge”) is connected to the macrocosm: “Son Rien, son Microcosme, unira à son Tout” (3, v.994; “His Nothingness, his Microcosm, he will unite with God’s All”).

7> It is Orpheus, the god associated with metempsychosis, who interrupts Adam’s dream:[15]

“Et d’un long son trainant sensiblement plus dous
Transformoit les brutaux, et les rudes sur tous
En forts hommes adroits. Dont l’Homme s’espouvante.” (2, v.989-91)

“And through a long, drawn out sound much softer
Transformed the brutes and wild beasts
Into strong able men, which/who frighten(s) our Man.”

Noise and transformation/transmigration images from animals to men frighten Adam into awakening, though the passage could also suggest the ambiguously civilizing power of music. The allusion to the god as teacher of reincarnation, as harbinger of knowledge from previous times, may foreshadow the ambiguous destiny of Adam’s heirs. Though the first book of Scève’s poem is a paraphrase of the book of Genesis, describing the fall from grace, fratricide, flight, and despair, and though restitution happens through Christ’s redeeming deed as well as the divine plan symbolized by the three books of 1000 verse and a three-verse epilogue, I would emphasize that Scève gives free rein to human perfectibility.[16] By presenting, in the second book of the Microcosme, Adam’s dream of the knowledge of the world and of his own self, the development of humanity and skills, and by adding a third book about telling these facts, the poet makes knowing and willing, which according to ancient psychology are the double tasks of the soul, central topics of his work. In emphasizing the ambiguous nature of the mind in its pursuit of finite microcosmic knowledge which will lead later−with Pascal, for example−to knowledge of the infinite universe, the poet opens up endless possibilities for the future.

A Journey through the Cosmos (of Love): Transmigration in “L’Amour des amours” (1555)

8> In 1555, Jacques Peletier du Mans made the journey through the microcosm and macrocosm of love his leitmotif in L’Amour des amours.[17] Peletier’s cycle is divided into two parts: first, 96 sonnets dedicated to the winged goddess of fame (fama pennata) who also seems to figure as the poet’s elusive mistress if we read, for example, the dedicatory poem entitled “A la fame” as “A la femme” and if we take into account the incorporeality of the lady in sonnets 55 and 57 as well as the golden branch offered by her in sonnet 18.[18] A series of cosmic poems forms the second part. The first part of this collection is dedicated to (Petrarchan) love, whereas in the second part, the Muse Urania, the “celestial one,” muse of the stars and of astronomy, initiates the soul of the poet into arcane knowledge: after tasting terrestrial love and knowledge, he will gain insights into celestial love, philosophy, and cosmology (Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn). Both sequences are linked through the image of the flight of the poet’s soul across the universe during which Fama serves as a faithful guide. Clearly, metempsychosis functions as the centerpiece of this work by Peletier.

9> If the cosmic journey is a trope which the author claims to have revived for French Renaissance poetry, such a conscious choice could open up the field for speculation with regard to the reception of metempsychosis in the French Renaissance.[19] From its source in book ten of Plato’s Republic (614b), Renaissance readers conclude that the individual soul, not being a body and not being composed, but related to the divine and living primarily, is related to the world soul and immortal, whereas the body is mortal and its resurrection impossible. Those souls that at their separation from a body did not purify themselves reunite in metempsychosis with a body that corresponds to their own inclinations. A revival of such theories, which are influenced by Plotinus’ theory of the soul, happens, among others, in Ficino’s Theologica Platonica (1474). Though the author denies that transmigration is a Platonic concept, but claims that it needs to be read allegorically, Renaissance discussions concerning it can be found in Pico, Savonarola, and Palmieri.[20] It appears that Johannes Reuchlin and Agrippa von Nettesheim reject it and that the Reformers Huldrych Zwingli and Théodore de Bèze are aware of it without taking a stance.[21] Metempsychosis will become an important topic in the Cabala del cavallo pegaseo (1585) where Giordano Bruno lets the Cillenican ass say: “Non esser cossí fiero, o Micco, e ricordati ch’il tuo Pitagora insegna di non spreggiar cosa che si trove nel seno della natura. Benché io sono in forma d’asino al presente, posso esser stato e posso esser appresso in forma di grand’uomo; e benché tu sia un uomo, puoi esser stato e potrai esser appresso un grand’asino, secondo che parrà ispediente al dispensator de gli abiti e luoghi e disponitor de l’anime transmigranti”[22] (“Don’t be so proud, o Fool, and remember that your Pythagoras teaches not to despise things that are found in the bosom of nature. Though I presently am in the shape of an ass, I may have been and might yet appear in the shape of a great man; and though you are a man, you may have been and might yet appear a great ass, according to what will seem expedient to the distributor of clothes and places, and the dispatcher of transmigrant souls”). While it is not Bruno’s ironic warning alone−not to deride an ass that may, in another life, have been a great man and not to admire a man who may once have been a great ass−which brings on his death at the stake in 1600, the danger of discussing transmigration is substantial. It certainly could be said that in L’Amour des amours Peletier not only juxtaposes traditional love themes and innovative, “scientific” themes in poetic guise while in the second part he thus pushes out the boundaries of the cosmos in a fictitious, hypothetical, and therefore inoffensive context. But in order to link the first and second part of his cycle, he employs an image that may become risky in the course of the Counter-Reformation.

10> At the beginning of its progress, in “L’Amour volant,” the soul first develops the ability to travel by sprouting wings reminiscent of a passage in Plato’s Phaidros (251): “Je sàn des pointes an mon ame/ De tous les cotez s’elancer,/ E nouveau cors me balancer” (101 v.4; “I feel wingtips in my soul/ Shoot up at every side/ And a new body rock me”). Fama/femme then guides the soul through its apprenticeship, which involves overcoming its initial fear of traveling through liquid ether that does not carry, so that in a short time it vanquishes its anxiety and becomes accustomed to movement.[23] Comprehension begins in the poem “Le Parnase,” where the soul gets to see a different aspect of its guide: “An ce haut lieu je la connoé/ Moins severe (chose voyable)/ E plus belle (chose incroyable)/ Qu’an moe je ne la façonnoé” (105 v.9; “In this high place/ I find her Less severe (visibly)/ And more beautiful (incredibly)/ Than to myself I imagined her”). Then follows a series of epiphanies linked to sense perception: “Je voè l’etroete region...” (106 v.33), “De loin je suis apercevant (106 v.41), “Mes espriz a l’ouvert humoet...” (107 v.46), “Ce l’ét, ma vue n’ét point veine...” (107 v.50), “Je voè desja au prochein val...” (107 v.57), “Or ça, dit el’, ne voés tu pas...” (108 v.73).[24] The soul then perceives Urania and the Castalian source and is told that the reason for its journey is that man’s vain efforts at cognition need the help of Fama to follow the lead of love’s attraction and to recognize the good: “Amour t’à ici attirè,...”[25] (“Love has drawn you here,…”).

11> Fama then exhorts the soul of the poet to remember well all that it has seen. It should be able to go back to earth as well as to return again to the heavens, which amounts to a repetition of the journey or even, in an allusion, to a reincarnation: “Contample moe ces chans divins,/ Connoè le genie e l’honore:/ E pour y retourner encore,/ Retièn bien par ou tu y vins” (112 v.178) (“Contemplate these divine fields,/ Know genius and honor it:/ And to return again,/ Remember how you came”).[26] It is notable here that both the soul and reason are individualized, and that the soul quite evidently has a cosmic character. Thanks to the Muses’ song the poet will then achieve understanding (115 v.217) and he will be able to describe his experience according to his abilities: “Ce chant naïf j’è retouchè/ Einsi que je l’è pù comprandre...” (117 v.257) (“This original song I have touched up/ As I was able to understand it....”).[27] The resulting cosmic harmony resounds in the air which is imagined both as liquid substance, as God’s writing table, and as a receptacle for divine song.

12> In Peletier’s Amour des amours, the soul does not experience death, but a different dimension of being that could be read as a continuation of its existence without transition. This would mean that for the author the soul is immortal. The body is not necessarily regarded as a prison, but it seems as if the soul could return and disclose to the terrestrial space what it has seen. Both the terrestrial and the celestial spheres coexist and seem to permit an exchange; they are of a permeable nature. The soul is seen as the center of a person and has the gift to perceive the eternal in exceptional circumstances, for example, if the poet is particularly talented. The poet’s soul may thus experience transmigration. Perception, which is illustrated by the frequent mention of the eye and the many verbs of seeing, and memory, which is illustrated by Fama who tells the poet to remember the way he came so that he can return alone at a later date, are important aspects as well as the will to recount the story of the journey. Faith and “experientia” are combined in the first and second part of the work respectively, because the soul discovers revelation in such a way that the poet will be able to narrate it afterwards. In this view of reincarnation, the soul is a substance distinguished and distinguishable from the body. This immortal soul creates all things and shapes a (poetic) world. Metempsychosis here legitimizes the poet’s status and the superiority of poetic discourse. In this way, it helps the poet acquire poetic skills, and, at the same time, he may present new worlds to the reader.

Ambiguous Mediators: Demons, Plants, Animals, and Philosophy in Ronsard’s “Hymnes” (1555, 1556) and “Le chat” (1569)

13> Shortly after Peletier’s Amour des amours, Pierre de Ronsard publishes his two volumes of Hymnes in 1555 and August 1556. In these texts, the author approaches natural philosophy with a combination of occult, magic, and experimental elements typical of Renaissance “scientific poetry” and celebrates, according to Jean Céard, the strength of human reason by cautioning at the same time against its fallacies.[28] Reincarnation through metamorphosis is one of Ronsard’s favorite motifs, as seen in his sonnet cycles Les Amours. Therefore, I propose to verify whether it may not constitute more in the hymns than a mere poetic kinship or a kind of exile topos.[29]

14> In the demonology of his “Hymne des Daimons” (1555), Ronsard stipulates that God made creatures for water, earth, air, and heaven. Demons are part of group three, their realm has certain limits, and they are of a changeable, mutable, or ambiguous nature. Their mutability is emphasized by a series of verbs denoting transformation (“muer,” “changent,” “transformé,” “s’eslargissent,” “s’etressissent”) and by the statement that, like the human being, they are mixed creatures consisting of serene respirations and passionate evaporations.[30] Good demons detach the human soul from the body whose prisoner it is in order to free it for a journey into the cosmos about which it then will tell man. The poet implies that the soul will return, for, in addition to guiding it, the good demons also are responsible for prophetic and divinely inspired dreams: “Les bons [...] r’emportent à DIEU noz faictz & nos prieres,/ Et detachent du corps noz ames prisonnieres/ Pour les mener là-haut, à fin d’imaginer/ Ce qui se doit sçavoir pour nous endoctriner” (197 vv.209-14; “The good ones [...] take up to God our deeds and our prayers,/ And detach from the body our imprisoned souls/ In order to lead them up to imagine/ What needs to be known to them in order to teach us”). Not only is the demons’ nature uncertain, they do ambiguous work, they can be dispensed with by believers, and they can be chased by using the magic word of God.[31] Moreover Ronsard’s attitude toward them is not only ambivalent, as has been underlined by Jean Céard,[32] but engaging in the development of a demonology already is an equivocal undertaking: demons compete with God because they interfere with his omnipresence and omniscience. This will be made clear by Jean Bodin, who in the first chapter of the first book of De la démonomanie des sorciers (1580) gives definitions of spirits and demons; he emphasizes that Christians understand “demons” to mean evil spirits and reminds his readers that in 1398 the Paris Faculty of Theology condemned as heretics those who maintained that there are good demons.

15> In the “Hymne de la Philosophie” (1555), the demons’ function is carried out by philosophy that detaches our imprisoned soul in order to lead it to the stars by means of “esprit,” that is, reason, ether, or “spiritus.” It is philosophy that travels through the universe, allying itself with the stars, and aiming at a glimpse of the divine in order to then open the soul’s eyes: “Elle, voyant qu’à l’homme estoit nyé/ D’aller au Ciel, disposte, a delié/ Loing, hors du corps, nostre Ame emprisonnée,/ Et par esprit aux astres l’a menée”[33] (“Seeing that it was denied to man/ To go to Heaven, she readily untied/ From the body our imprisoned Soul,/ And through the ether led it to the stars”). In the “Hymne de la mort” (1555), finally, the same image is elaborated to include a reason for the human being’s suffering: man is a prisoner cuffed and chained, who must be rejoicing at the moment of his liberation through death. Like Plato, Ronsard considers the body to be the prison of the soul or the soul’s tomb.[34] The second part of the comparison, which is introduced by “Ainsi” in this poem, develops the idea that man should rejoice when death undoes his ties in order to free him from the bonds of misery:

“Mais où est cestuy-là, s’il n’est bien miserable,
Et lourd d’entendement, qui ne veuille estre hors
De l’humaine prison de ce terrestre corps?
Ainsi qu’un prisonnier qui jour et nuict endure
Les manicles aux mains, aux pieds la cheine dure,
Se doit bien resjouir à l’heure qu’il se voit
Delivré de prison: ainsi l’homme se doit
Resjouir grandement, quand la MORT luy delye
Le lien qui tenoit sa miserable vie, . . .”[35]

“But where is the one who, unless he is quite miserable
And hard of understanding, would not want to be out
Of the human prison of this terrestrial body?
Like a prisoner who day and night endures
Cuffs on hands, and hard chain on his feet,
Must well rejoice at the hour he sees himself
Delivered from prison: thus man must
Rejoice loudly when Death unties
The bond that tied his miserable life, . . .”

16> Death, a female deity,[36] is ambiguous, as for the common man it separates the body from the soul, whereas for the philosopher it separates the soul from the body. Yet death ultimately is embraced as a desired separation of soul and body, a liberation, in “L’Hymne de la mort,”[37] whereas in the other two poems the journey to the beyond is a repeated occurrence thanks to the demons and to philosophy.

17> If man’s grasp of arcane knowledge is due to his angelic and demonic double nature, in the “Hymne des Daimons” he is regarded as immortal in so far as one of the two parts of which he is composed derives from God who is all-powerful and eternal: “Or’ deux extremitez ne sont point sans milieu,/ Et deux extremitez sont les hommes et DIEU./ DIEU, qui est tout-puissant, de nature eternelle,/ Les hommes, impuissans, de nature mortelle:/ Des hommes & de DIEU, les DAIMONS aërins/ Sont communs en nature,…”[38] (“Now two extremes are not without a mean:/ the two extremes are man and GOD:/ GOD who is all-powerful and of eternal nature,/ And powerless man of mortal nature:/ Of men and GOD the demons of the air partake…”). Yet we may say that in Ronsard’s view the divine is always counterbalanced by an awareness of “experientia.” Demons for the poet are a means to explain supernatural events without encroaching on religious matters, which thus remain untouched by human intelligence. In the “Hymne des daimons” he ventures to give a detailed description of these creatures’ constitution and of their partly divine, partly human nature as well as their categorization into good and bad demons.[39] For Ronsard, demons fulfill the same function that spirits fulfilled for Peletier in L’Amour des amours: they are mediators between the different strata of the cosmos and they help man acquire scientific and poetic knowledge through useful links.[40]

18> In Ronsard’s demonology, demons have bodies of the same nature as spirits. They are both soul and spirit and may therefore influence the soul and the spirit of man. Yet for writers of the sixteenth century, it is a risky undertaking to combine “spiritus” and soul, “spiritus mundi” with its children and “spiritus” in the sense of the Holy Ghost. It remains impossible to align the medical theory of spirits with Christian psychology, because the spirit tends from his mediator position to become dominant so as to leave hardly any room for a transcendent and incorporeal soul.[41] As the “spiritus” is the soul’s competitor, between matter and spirit, it is ambiguous, suspect, and may even be considered as heretical. In addition, venturing outward into the cosmos and the space of demons means that the poet pushes upward and enlarges the scope of human intelligence beyond the limits set by theologians. This is why there are noticeable changes in the 1584 edition of the Hymnes: philosophy becomes a saint in the “Hymne de la Philosophie” and the author omits, in the “Hymne des daimons,” the scientific account of the demons’ origin as well as an autobiographical passage concerning an encounter with a group of ghosts in which he attempts a comparative anatomy.

19> In the demonology of the “Hymne des daimons,” Ronsard maintains that demons may appear in the shape of cats (Hymnes, 194 v.106). Yet in his poem “Le chat” (1569) he names several (animal) signs that announce disagreeable events and that can be attributed to God, whose presence permeates the world as soul, according to the beginning of the text:

“Dieu est par tout, par tout se mesle Dieu,
Commencement, la fin, & le milieu
De ce qui vit, & dont l’Ame est enclose
Par tout, & tient en vigueur toute chose,
Come nostre Ame infuse dans noz corps.
Ja des longtemps les membres seroient morts
De ce grand Tout, si cette Ame divine
Ne se mesloit par toute la Machine,
Luy donnant vie & force & mouvement:
Car de tout estre elle est commencement.”[42]

“God is everywhere, everywhere works God,
Beginning, end, and middle
Of what lives, and whose soul is enclosed
Everywhere, and keeps everything alive,
Like our soul instilled in our bodies.
Long ago the parts would have died
Of this great All, if this divine soul
Did not work in the entire machine,
Giving it life and force and movement:
For of all being it is the beginning.”

20> God is the giver of an all-embracing soul that is as perfect and eternal as he is himself.[43] This soul permeates the earth that is regarded as a mother who engenders life.[44] Ronsard here refers to ideas of the Averroists: they believe that the soul is divided into the functions that it has to fulfill; they also try to determine whether the thinking, rational soul is immortal and whether it is immortal as individual soul or only as universal reason.[45] Thus they deny that our souls are individual units. Accordingly, Ronsard names prophetic plants, as, for example, a laurel tree whose sudden death caused by a demon brings on the poet’s fever (vv.71-100). There also are prophetic animals: a horse that provokes a servant’s death whose last words are considered as an omen which once again precedes the poet’s fever (vv.101-110). A quarter of the poem is dedicated to Ronsard’s personal hatred for cats; this is illustrated in an encounter with such an animal, an event that provokes some speculations concerning animal signs. This leads to a final passage on the manifestation of the divine in animals. While it is certainly correct, as has been shown by Jean Céard, that there are classical sources for the discussion on pantheism, – one of them, Aratos, is even mentioned by the poet –, it remains important to stress the typical humanist way of adapting ancient sources to contemporary use:[46] “Le chat” is dedicated to Remy Belleau whose epitaph Ronsard composed and who translated the Phainomena, the cosmology of Aratos, one part of which describes the transformation of beings into stars. In addition, one of the articles condemned by the Lateran Council in 1513 is the Averroistic doctrine of the unity of the intellect. On the other end of the spectrum there is Bruno’s statement “Natura est deus in rebus” from Lo Spaccio della bestia trionfante, a statement which makes the universe indistinguishable from the divine. Whereas in the hymns Ronsard still balances human and divine intellect, in “Le chat” he engages in unapproved deliberations. Yet the poem may also be read as a satyrical metempsychosis, similar to the one of Lucian’s rooster in the dream of the shoemaker Michyllus.

The All-Encompassing Protestant Soul in Du Bartas’s Creation (1578, 1584)

21> Though Guillaume Salluste Du Bartas, in his monumental cycles of creation, the Première Sepmaine (1578) and the Seconde Sepmaine (1584), does not present a heliocentric worldview 35 years after the death of Copernicus, he celebrates creation by giving a near-complete inventory of the universe in which man is a second God, endowed with a “fifth essence,” the soul.[47] This “quinta essentia” defined by Aristotle in De Caelo (1.2, 3) as heavenly substance and as the nature of the innate spirit in De Generatione Animae (2.3, 736b), is taken up in the sense of cosmic spirit by Ficino, by the alchemists, and by Fernel in the fourth book of De naturali parte medicinae (1542). Yet the soul for Du Bartas is likewise suspended between God and the human body and is divinely inspired, as the poet indicates in the encomiastic turn at the beginning of his work: “[Pere] Esleve à toy mon ame, espure mes esprits,/ Et d’un docte artifice enrichi mes escrits” (1.5) (“Lift up to you my soul, purify my mind, And by learned art enrich my writings”).

22> That the soul is imprisoned by corporeal matter seems to be Du Bartas’s opinion on the second day of his Première Sepmaine: here the wicked coat of the rebellious body presses down on the soul like a heavy counterweight: “Ou bien, que deschargé du manteau vicieux/ De ce rebelle corps, qui mon ame sans cesse/ D’un pesant contrepoids en bas presse et represse” (2.948). In this image we may see a faint allusion to the weaver’s coat that is mentioned by Cebes, one of the interlocutors in Plato’s Phaidon (87b-c). In the seventh book, Du Bartas reiterates the disparity of body and soul: “Ains qu’il [l’Eternel] logea nostre ame en un vaisseau de terre,/ Plus liquide que l’eau, plus fresle que le verre./ Il sçait que rien plus tost ne nous guide au trespas,/ Qu’avoir tousjours tendus les esprits et les bras” (7.367) (“As he lodged our soul in a vessel of earth,/ More liquid than water, more fragile than glass./ He knows that nothing helps us more in our passing/ Than to always have lifted our minds and our arms”). In the Seconde Sepmaine, Du Bartas maintains once more that the earth is merely a prison, an abbyss, and the worst of graves (“Ce n’est qu’une prison, une averne effroyable,/ Et du monde premier le tombeau miserable,” 3.9).[48] While we may therefore assume that the author considers death as a desired separation of soul and body, he describes, at the same time, reincarnation in an alchemical image:

“Presque en mesme moment de ce cendreux monceau
Naist un ver, puis un oeuf, et puis un autre oiseau,
Ainçois le mesme oiseau, qui né de sa semence,
Deux cens lustres nouveaux, trespassant recommence,
Au milieu du brasier sa belle ame reprend,
Infini par sa fin dans la tombe se rend,
De soy mesme se fait, par une mort prospere,
Nourrice, nourrisson, hoir, fils, et pere et mere:
Nous monstrant qu’il nous fait et de corps et d’esprit
Mourir tous en “Adam,” pour puis renaistre en Christ.” (5.589-98)

“Almost at the same moment, out of this ashen pile,
Comes a worm, then an egg, and then another bird,
But the same bird, born from its seed,
Two hundred new lights, passing beyond begins anew,
In the middle of the flames takes up again its beautiful soul,
Infinitely by its end returns to its tomb,
Transforms itself by a prosperous death into
Nurse, nursling, heir, son, and mother and father:
Showing us that it makes us all in body and soul
Die in “Adam” to then be reborn in Christ.”

23> Like the phoenix, the human soul dies in the human body, but is resurrected in Christ. Thus, divine creation must be contrasted with purely human efforts that only produce a soulless mass: “Mais l’artifice humain ne produit seulement/ Une masse sans ame, un corps sans mouvement” (6.833-4; “But human art only produces/ A mass without soul, a body without movement”). According to Du Bartas, man has a purely mechanic talent of imitation.

24> In order to examine the soul, the poet dissects it, like the rest of the body, on the sixth day. He does so by drawing on the French tradition of the blason, i.e. poems minutely describing the qualities of individual body parts, as well as on the craft of dissection that had been publicized by Vesalius. By taking up the scalpel, Du Bartas lays bare the nerves of the brain:

“Prendray-je la scalpelle
Pour voir les cabinets de la double cervelle,
Thresoriere des arts, source du sentiment,
Siege de la raison, fertil commencement
Des nerfs de nostre corps:” (6.643-7)

“Will I take the scalpel
to see the double chambers of the brain,
Treasurer of the arts, source of feeling,
Seat of reason, fertile beginning
Of our body’s nerves.”

“Pourray-je desployer sur un docte fueillet
Ce Dedale subtil, cest admirable reth
Par les replis duquel l’esprit monte et devale,
Rendant sa faculté de vitale, Animale:” (6.653-6)

“Could I display on a learned sheet
This subtle maze, this wonderful net
Through whose meshes the spiritus rises and descends
Restoring its vital to animal faculty.”

25> The results are, however, disappointing for the modern reader, as they are influenced, on the one hand, by Galen’s observation of an ox and, on the other hand, by the Pythagorean idea that one production of brain matter is sperm. Thus, the soul remains Aristotelian, but, according to the poet, does have the capacity to fly:

“Or bien que nostre esprit vive comme captif
Dans les ceps de ce corps, qu’il languisse chetif
Sous un obscur tombeau, d’une tirade il vole
Et d’Imave outre Calpe, et de la terre au pole:
Plus viste que celuy qui d’un flamboyant tour,
Tout ce grand Univers postillonne en un jour.
Car quittant quelquefois les terres trop conues,
D’une alegre secousse il saute sur les nues,
Il noue par les airs, où, subtil, il aprend
Dequoy se fait la neige, et la gresle, et le vent:
Dequoy se fait l’esclair, la glace, la tempeste,
La pluye, le tonnerre, et la triste comete.” (6.789-800)

“Although our spirit lives like captive
In the shackles of this body, though it wretchedly languishes
Under a dark tomb, by a leap it flies
From one end of the world to the other:
Faster than the one who by a blazing course
Traverses this great Universe in a day.
For, sometimes leaving these too well known lands
By a sprightly leap it springs on the clouds,
It speeds through the airs, where, discerning, it learns
Of what snow is made, hale, and wind:
Of what the lightning is made, the ice, the storm,
The rain, the thunder, and the sad comet.”

In fact, La Seconde Sepmaine, in addition to depicting the perfect state of Adam who is in regular dialogue with God, has Du Bartas the poet embark on a cosmic journey that reminds us of Peletier, with the difference that this journey leads to the dream of Paradise in the Suite de la Seconde Sepmaine.[49] Here, Paradise is the dwelling place of Eloquence, which is consequently divinely inspired.

26> How does man perceive things in general and eventually recognize what he is destined to attain, that is, the divine? For Du Bartas, perception looks as follows:

“Je sçay que comme l’oeil void tout fors que soi-mesme,
Que nostre ame conoit toutes choses de mesme,
Fors que sa propre essence: et qu’elle ne peut pas
Mesurer sa grandeur de son propre compas.
Mais comme l’oeil qui n’est offensé d’un caterre,
Se void aucunement dans l’onde ou dans le verre,
Nostre ame tout ainsi se contemple à peu-pres
Dans le luisant miroir de ses effects sacrez.”[50]

“I know that, like the eye which sees all except itself,
Our soul equally knows all things
Except its own essence: and that it cannot
Gauge its greatness by its own measure.
But like the eye which is not clouded by the humors
Sees itself somewhat in water or in a glass,
Our soul equally contemplates itself somewhat
In the shiny mirror of its holy deeds.”

Perception will always be thwarted, for the eye as well as the soul can only indirectly perceive themselves either in a mirror or in the mirror of their effect. The poet maintains that it is the contemplation of nature that should lead to recognition and knowledge (7. 435-40). “Experientia” seems to be the key to progress and faith, at the same time, is not an obstacle when man is invited to read in the world as in a book. Such a cosmic view is in harmony with the poet’s opinion that man is the king of animals, because he masters nature by way of language that helps him appropriate reality (6.946; 6 vv.483 and 927-934). Situated between God and the earth, the human being has an immediate relationship with the former and constitutes the essence of the latter: “Et bref l’homme n’est rien qu’un abregé du monde,/ Un tableau racourci, que sur l’autre Univers/ Je veux ore tirer du pinceau de mes vers” (6.406).

Bretonnayau and the Cosmic Temple of the Soul (1583)

27> In 1583, René Bretonnayau publishes La Génération de l’homme et le temple de l’âme avec Autres oeuvres Poëtiques extraittes de l’Esculape, a long poem half medical-empirical, half philosophical that is dedicated to the king’s brother.[51] Its title also refers to the poems of the “rhétoriqueurs,” a group of writers who compose precious verse, and in particular to one of their late representatives, Clément Marot, who wrote an allegorical eclogue entitled Temple de Cupidon. Du Bartas’s description of man on day six of his divine week may also have inspired our poet. Yet this work of 1,888 verses turns out to be an anatomical observation of the human skull laid down in heroic verse (alexandrines) and almost hymn-like tones. In his introduction, the Protestant and Paracelsian author[52] states that he is conscious of composing an innovative literary genre: “Oeuvre laborieux, sur nul autre imité,/ Temple, que le premier à la divinité/ De l’ame ie basty, le premier ie dedie/ A l’ame, qui de l’homme est l’immortelle vie” (55r) (“Laborious work, not modeled after any other, /Temple which I am the first to have built/ To the soul which is the immortal life of man”). Having thus defined the soul as everlasting, he invites all readers to his monument, “le tabernacle humain de l’ame le sacraire” (55v) (“the human tabernacle, the shrine of the soul”), except for those who consider the soul as perishable, that is, the followers of “atheist” Protagoras and “dirty” Epicurus.[53]

28> Bretonnayau describes the creation of the macrocosm and of the microcosm: “Chere Muse dy moy comme a esté bastie/ De l’humain Microcosme à part chasque partie:/ Et commençons au chef, qui tient un pareil lieu/ A l’ame, que le ciel tient au regard de Dieu” (57r) (“Dear Muse, tell me how were built/ the separate parts of he human Microcosm:/ And let us start with the head that has the same function/ for the soul as does the heaven for God’s gaze”). Accordingly, throughout the text, the poet engages in cosmic comparisons, in a long analogy typical of contemporary prose texts and poetry cycles.[54] Yet Bretonnayau differs from them by concentrating on the head, not in the sense of Plato’s Timaeus or of the Church’s official anatomy which propagates three spheric ventricles: instead he admires God’s artisanship in the formation of the parts of the crane whose suturations he describes in a way that reminds the reader of Vesalius’ illustrations to De humani corporis fabrica (1543):

“Le maistre tout faisant, qui le Crane bastit
En huict os, comble & fond, sagement compartit
Pour la commodité: car si un os se casse,
N’y a qu’un os cassé, la playe n’outrepasse
Ses orlets dentelez, & l’autre plus prochain
Ne se sentant du coup demeure entier & sain:” (61r)

“The all-making master, who built the Crane,
In eight bones altogether wisely divided
For convenience: for if a bone breaks
There is only one bone broken, the wound does not go beyond
Its jagged borders, & and the other next to it
Does not feel the blow and remains intact.”

29> Plate 5 from the first book of the De humani corporis fabrica shows the skull shape with the sutures (5:1, 5:8).[55] It is possible that Bretonnayau gets the notion of diploe[56] from Galen who had already described it, but it is Vesalius who pictures it:[57]

“C’est os, le Tout-ouvrier, d’artifice admirable
Recama par dessous d’une seconde table
Mince, mais pourtant forte, entre ces doubles os.
Ce que le Dyploé on appelle, est enclos
Tout plein d’humeur moüelleux, . . .”(61v)

“This bone, the Maker with wonderful art
Stitched underneath a second table
Slender, but strong, between these double bones.
What is called diploe is enclosed
Full of moisture, . . .”

This protective shell is neither too thick nor too thin and therefore just right to contain the soul. Not only are the turns of Phoebus compared to the spheres of the brain/globe (62r), but the lowest part of the brain also corresponds to the moon: “Des tantes du cerveau nous en reste encor une/ De toutes la plus basse, ainsi qu’aux Cieux la lune” (62v) (“Among the domes of the brain there is still one left that is of all the lowest, as is the moon in the Heavens”). The comparisons continue up to the cosmic harmony which is in unison with that of the human soul: “Tels sont du petit ciel avecque le tresgrand/ Les accords, cestuy Dieu, l’autre l’ame comprend:/ Voyons aussi qu’elle est la divine harmonie/ De l’ame avecque Dieu humainement unie” (63v) (“Such are the agreements of the small heaven with the great,/ the latter comprises God, the former the soul:/ Let us also see what is the divine harmony/ of the Soul humanly united with God”).

30> As it is for Du Bartas, the soul is a fifth essence for Bretonnayau also (65v). In order to gain knowledge, it embarks on a journey, freely leaving and reentering the body, and traveling in order to convey dreams to the human being. The poet’s example is the Queen mother who is pregnant with the king’s brother. She dreams of giving birth to a laurel tree whose fruit is peace and that is contested by Apollo and Mars in a war of winds (73v). It resists long enough to be finally protected by Apollo and it is left to grow in order to give prosperous shade to the people of France (74r). In the same way that good people can have confidence in such dreams sent by God (74v), unreasonable minds will be sent incomprehensible dreams, just as Ronsard suggests in his demonology. This leads Bretonnayau to warn against many pregnant mothers’ overactive imagination that may cause monstrous births (75v). After a poetic description of the cerebellum and the ventricles as temple-like constructs, this poem, like Ronsard’s “Le chat,” ends with a pantheistic description of the world soul.

Conclusion

31> While the French Renaissance poets whom I have chosen for my analysis partly depict the relationship between body and soul in stock images from classical sources, all of them, in their endeavor to describe and situate the soul, propose outlooks on empirical observation. Scève develops a concept of perfectibility on the basis of human intelligence. Peletier’s transmigration opens up a view of cosmic landscapes. Ronsard’s daring display of mediating forces between the human soul and God reduces the role of the divine. Du Bartas’ eclectic view of the soul is in direct communication with God, but the poet is ready to embrace the entirety of contemporary science. Bretonnayau’s anatomy of the human skull loses itself in descriptions quite regardless of divine power. Such accumulations are, on the one, hand typical of the encyclopaedic Renaissance style, but, on the other hand, useful as a subterfuge: for the occupation with humanistic thought and its presentation in verse is certainly worthwhile, but as such not quite interesting enough. Yet even the mere listing of supposedly empirical facts at the expense of religious precepts may become risky in the end and the poet would like to stay alive. Therefore empirical fact needs to be presented such that it is not clearly empirical, because otherwise empirical research is not possible any longer. On the other hand, it is tempting to deal with it, because otherwise these poems would not have been written at all.

32> The abundance of theories concerning the nature of the soul and the question of transmigration, be it in scientific or poetic terms, likewise interest Michel de Montaigne who concludes:

“[L]’entendement humain se perdant à vouloir sonder et contreroller toutes choses jusques au bout; tout ainsi comme, lassez et travaillez de la longue course de nostre vie, nous retombons en enfantillage.−Voylà les belles et certaines instructions que nous tirons de la science humaine sur le subject de nostre ame.”[58]

“Human understanding loses itself wanting to probe and examine everything to its end; likewise we ourselves, weary and tired from life’s long journey, fall back into childishness.−These are the beautiful and definite findings that we get from human science on the subject of our soul.”

The author distinguishes between “l’entendement humain,” that is, reason, the intellect, the mind on the one hand and “âme” on the other hand, which in this passage could mean the immortal soul; about the latter we cannot have scientific knowledge.

33> Scève, Peletier, Ronsard, Du Bartas, and Bretonnayau of course intend to celebrate, through a poetics of immortality, the immortality of their own work. Yet to render eternal the poet is only part of their endeavor. Where human science is not advanced enough to solidly confirm new findings or their hypotheses, where theologians prevent a direct engagement with empirical fact, poetic representation enables to open doors to a new age. As the cosmic dimension of the texts discussed is not of great interest, the intention of these Renaissance poets may have been, by a detour, to enable inquiry to take place nevertheless. For their professions of faith, Catholic or Protestant, genuine or preventive, cannot deflect from the fact that their infinitely detailed description of the abilities of the human mind in connection with cosmic dimensions is a fascinating topic which ultimately points to the description of an infinite universe.

Notes:

1. Michel de Montaigne, Les Essais (Paris: Gallimard, 1962) 3.13, 1087 c. “Aristippus only defended the body, as if we had no soul; Zenon only embraced the soul, as if we had no body. Both were mistaken.” (All translations are mine.)

2. These texts are pre-Cartesian in the sense that the thinking soul is not as a rule identified with the mind, because for Descartes the mind or soul is as a nonmaterial entity exclusive to human beings; it lacks extension and motion, does not follow the laws of physics, and interacts with the body at the pineal gland.

3. I would like to thank Christoph Lüthy for encouraging such an approach.

4. La poésie scientifique en France au XVIe siècle (Paris: A. Michel, 1938).

5. “The Cosmic Voyage in French Sixteenth-Century Learned Poetry,” Studies in the Renaissance X (1963): 136-62.

6. La Poésie du ciel en France dans la seconde moitié du seizième siècle (Geneva: Droz, 1995) 495, 498.

7. Evidently, this is not a complete corpus, as Pontus de Tyard or Guy Le Fèvre de La Boderie are missing. I omitted the latter’s description of the soul in the Encyclie (1571), for example, because it is entirely indebted to the official doctrine of the Catholic church.

8. Germaine Lafeuille, Cinq Hymnes de Ronsard (Geneva: Droz, 1973); Philip Ford, Ronsard’s Hymnes: a literary and iconographical study (Tempe, AZ.: Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, 1997); Anne-Pascale Pouey-Mounou, L’Imaginaire cosmologique de Ronsard (Geneva: Droz, 2002).

9. “Experientia” “consist in reports, mostly impersonal, of things sensed.” Propositions to be held by faith are “codified and warranted by the decisions of patriarchs, popes, synods, and councils, decisions not only on questions of faith but the manner of their resolution, and in particular the authority of texts.” Both determine the data of natural philosophy (Dennis Des Chene, Life’s Form. Late Aristotelian Conceptions of the Soul (Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 2000), 23, 45).

10. See, for example, Emily Michael, “Renaissance Theories of Body, Soul, and Mind,” Psyche and Soma. Physicians and metaphysicians on the mind-body problem from Antiquity to Enlightenment, ed. John P. Wright and Paul Potter (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2000), 147-172.

11. I am using mind rather than soul in order to account for Scève’s eclectic display of Aristotelian souls and the mental faculties of the brain, the Platonic ascent of the soul, or the immortal Soul.

12. Maurice Scève, Microcosme, ed. Enzo Giudici (Paris: Vrin, 1976), 3, v.25-6.

13. Significantly in books two and three, that are less directly based on the biblical source: “Par son intelligence, et par sa voulenté,/ Dont à bien, ou à mal, l’homme est entalenté” (Microcosme, 2, v.83-4; “Through his intelligence and his will/ That equips man for good or evil”). Later, Adam recognizes: “Me sentant intellect avecques voulonté/ A tout bien, à tout mal pront, et entalenté” (3, v.943; “I feel in me intellect with will/ readying and enabling me for all good and all bad”).

14. Jean Céard also mentions this passage in “Sens, coeur, raison, mémoire dans Délie: la psychologie de Scève,” in Françoise Charpentier, Lire Maurice Scève, Cahiers textuel 33/44, 1987, 15-25.

15. Plato, Republic 10.620a, in Complete Works, ed. John M. Cooper (Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1997). For a reading of orphic elements in Scève’s poetry, see James Helgeson, Harmonie divine et subjectivité poétique chez Maurice Scève (Geneva: Droz, 2001), 39-75.

16. I do not entirely agree with Cynthia Skenazi’s assessment that in the Microcosme Scève takes up the motifs of his Délie in order to rework them in a purely Christian spirit (Maurice Scève et la pensée chrétienne (Geneva: Droz, 1992), 45). I rather take my cue from Hans Staub’s connection of Scève and Cusanus (Le curieux désir. Scève et Peletier du Mans poètes de la connaissance (Geneva: Droz, 1967), 85-126) and from Enzio Giudici’s introduction to his edition of Microcosme (33-4); both scholars emphasize the civil and, as it were, non-theological nature of Scève’s poem.

17. For a short account of this poet’s life and multiple talents, see Sophie Arnaud, La voix de la nature dans l’oeuvre de Jacques Peletier du Mans (Paris: Champion, 2005), 19-21.

18. Sonnet 55 is a philosophical sonnet that plays with notions of divine talent, the finite, the infinite, and conjecture (Jacques Peletier du Mans, L’Amour des Amours, ed. Jean-Charles Monferran (Paris: Société des Textes Français Modernes, 1996), 68-9). As Hans Staub has proposed, it may be based on Cusa’s notion of conjecture (Le curieux désir, 21). In sonnet 57, a first and a second soul make up the celestial soul, that is, the princess of the sonnet (L’Amour des amours, 69-70).

19. “Donques voyant la France lasse/ De voler d’une ele si basse,/ Et chercher plus haute largeur,/ J’è levé plus haut ma volée,/ D’une ele qu’amour m’à colée,/ Pour de l’Er me faire nageur” (“A Madame Marguerite, Ode,” L’Amour des Amours, 193); “Seeing France tired/ Of flying on so low a wing/ And of looking for higher spheres,/ I have lifted higher my flight,/ With a wing that love gave me,/ In order to swim in the Air.”

20. In Matteo Palmieri’s Città di vita (Northampton, Mass.: Smith College, 1927-8) Book 1, Chapter 5 (“Quivi ne campi elysii fu raccolta…”).

21. Helmut Zander, Geschichte der Seelenwanderung in Europa (Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1999), 236-47.

22. Giordano Bruno, The cabala of Pegasus, tr. Sidney L. Sondergard and Madison U. Sowell (New Haven & London: Yale University Press, 2002), 148.

23. “Pour me garder de m’etonner/ Au regard de ces creus abimes,/ E an ces grans partours sublimes/ Garder mon cerveau de tourner,/ El’ me conforte e m’ilumine/ De l’er fecond de sa clerte,/ E de mes yeus la liberte/ De loin an loin elle termine” (L’Amour des Amours, 105 v.17-24).

24. In all quotes, emphasis is mine.

25. L’Amour des Amours, 110 v.129-111 v.152.

26. “Genie” can mean “âme,” “esprit,” “ombre d’un mort” (Edmond Huguet, Dictonnaire de la langue française du seizième siècle).

27. “Naïf” signifies “natif,” “originaire,” “naturel,” “exact,” “ressemblant,” “vrai,” or “donné par la nature” (Huguet, Dictionnaire).

28. Jean Céard, La nature et les prodiges: l’insolite au 16e siècle, en France (Geneva: Droz, 1996 (1977)), 192-94.

29. See Stephen Murphy, “Ronsard, Petrarca, Ennius, and Poetic Metempsychosis,” Romance Notes 32 (1991): 93-99; Michel Simonin, “Ronsard et l’exil de l’âme,” CAIEF 43 (1991): 25-44.

30. Pierre de Ronsard, Hymnes, ed. Albert Py (Geneva: Droz, 1978), 195 vv.153-64.

31. “Mais si quelqu’un les tente au nom du TRESPUISSANT,/ Ils vont hurlant, criant, tremblant, & fremissant,…” (Hymnes, 202 vv.413-4).

32. La nature et les prodiges, 208, 209, 213, 220.

33. Hymnes,164 v.21-4.

34. Gorgias 493a, Phaidros 250c, Laws 958c, Phaidon 80, Phaidros 248e-249b.

35. Hymnes, 230 v.48-56.

36. “C’est une grand’ Déesse” (Ibid., 230 v.41).

37. “O que d’estre ja mors nous seroit un grand bien,/ Si nous considerions que nous ne sommes rien/ Qu’une terre animée & qu’une vivante ombre,/ Le suject de douleur, de misere & d’ancombre!/ Voire, & que nous passons en miserables maux/ Le reste (ô crevecoeur!) de tous les animaux” (Ibid., 233 v.141-6).

38. Ibid., 196 vv.201-6.

39. “Ilz sont participans de DIEU, & des humains:/ De DIEU, comme immortelz, & de nous, comme pleins/ De toutes passions: ilz desirent, ilz craignent,/ Ilz veulent conçevoir, ilz ayment & dedaignent” (Ibid., 195 vv.157-60).

40. Albert-Marie Schmidt, La Poésie scientifique en France au XVIe siècle, 81 and 92. See also Pierre de Ronsard, Oeuvres Complètes (Paris: Gallimard, 1994), Vol.2, pp.1444 for a definition of the demons.

41. Michael Sonntag, “Gefährte der Seele, Träger des Lebens. Die medizinischen Spiritus im sechzehnten Jahrhundert,” Die Seele. Ihre Geschichte im Abendland, ed. Gerd Jüttemann, Michael Sonntag, Christoph Wulf (Weinheim: Psychologie Verlags Union, 1991), 172.

42. Pierre de Ronsard, Oeuvres complètes, ed. Paul Laumonier (Paris: Didier, 1953), 39 vv.1-10.

43. “De Dieu vient l’ame, & come il est parfait/ L’ame est parfaite, intouchable, immortelle,/ Come venant d’une Essence eternelle:/ L’Ame n’a doncq commencement ni bout:/ Car la Partie ensuit tousjours le Tout” (Ibid., vv.14-8).

44. “Mere benigne, à gros tetins foeconde, Au large sein...” (Ibid., v.24).

45. Michael Stadler, “Weltseele und Kosmos, Seele und Körper,” in Die Seele. Ihre Geschichte im Abendland, 189.

46. Jean Céard, La nature et les prodiges, 220-4.

47. “Il doit d’un second Dieu former le bastiment” (Guillaume de Salluste du Bartas, La Sepmaine, ed. Yvonne Bellenger (Paris: Nizet, 1981), 6.460). “Or ce docte Imager, pour son oeuvre animer,/ Ne prit de l’air, du feu, de terre, de la mer,/ Une cinquiesme essence, ains poussant son haleine,/ Il fit comme couler de la vive fontaine/ De sa Divinité quelque petit ruisseau/ Dans les sacrez conduits de ce fresle vaisseau” (6.709-14). (Emphasis is mine.) I have found very helpful the concordance in La Bibliothèque de Du Bartas, ed. James Dauphiné and Marie-Luce Demonet (Paris: Champion, 1994).

48. “Averne” comes from Lake Avernus, the entrance to the underworld in the Aeneid (6.237).

49. “Mais ce qui plus encor à nostre Ayeul agrée,/ Est le frequent commerce, et hantise sacrée,/ Que son ame et son corps avoient diversement/ Avec Dieu, qui d’Eden fait un clair Firmament” (Seconde Sepmaine (1584), ed. Yvonne Bellenger (Paris: Société des Textes Français modernes, 1991), 1.333-6). For the cosmic journey, see: “Hé! qui sera celuy qui me donra des aeles,/ A fin que devançant les vistes arondeles,/ En moins d’un tourne-main je vole, audacieux,/ Des cieux jusqu’aux enfers, des enfers jusqu’aux cieux?” (Seconde Sepmaine, 2.1-4); “Ce sera toy, mon Dieu, mon Dieu, ce sera toy,/ Qui sublimant mon ame au fourneau de la foy,... (Seconde Sepmaine, 2.23-4); “Où suis-je transporté? Je ne suis plus au monde...” (Seconde Sepmaine, 3.1).

50. La Sepmaine, 6.735-42.

51. La Génération de l’homme et le temple de l’âme avec Autres oeuvres Poëtiques extraittes de l’Esculape de René Bretonnayau medecin, natif de Vernantes en Anjou. A Paris, pour Abel l’Angelier, au premier pillier de la grand’salle du Palays. MDLXXXIII. Avec privilege du Roy. “Génération” here means both “generation, fabrication” and “nation, race, descendance” (Huguet, Dictionnaire).

52. Albert-Marie Schmidt, La Poésie scientifique en France au XVIe siècle, 282-4.

53. “Mais arriere bien loin, ô vous trouppe infidelle,/ Qui vous figurez l’ame une chose mortelle. [...] Retournez vous veautrer, pourceaux, dedans l’ordure/ D’un Protagore Athee, & d’un sale Epicure,...” (56r).

54. See in particular also Ebreo’s Dialoghi d’amore. For a general survey of Bretonnayau’s work, see Andrzej Dziedzic, “Entre l’art de guérir et l’art d’écrire: René Bretonnayau,” Mosaic 35:2 (2002), 73-91.

55. The Illustrations from the Works of Andreas Vesalius of Brussels, ed. J.B. Saunders and C. D. O’Malley (New York: Dover Publications, 1973), 52-3.

56. The soft, spongy, or cancellated substance between the plates of the skull (
www.biology-online.org/dictionary/Diploe).

57. Julius Rocca, Galen on the Brain (Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2003), 97. The Illustrations from the Works of Andreas Vesalius of Brussels, 52-3.

58. Les Essais, 2.12 538 a.
_____

Dorothea Heitsch, former Associate Professor of French at Shippensburg University and currently lecturer in French in the Department of Romance Languages at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, is the author of Practising Reform in Montaigne’s Essais (Brill, 2000). She has co-edited, with Jean-François Vallée, a collection of essays entitled Printed Voices: The Renaissance Culture of Dialogue (Toronto, 2004). She has published articles on Montaigne, Marie de Gournay, Antoine de la Sale, Leone Ebreo, and Hélisenne de Crenne. She is finishing a book manuscript on Empiricism and Literature and is Representative of Fixed-Term Faculty on the MLA Executive Council (2010-2014).
_____

APPOSITIONS: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature & Culture, http://appositions.blogspot.com/, ISSN: 1946-1992, Volume Three (2010): Digital Archives

Colleen Kennedy: "Deodorizing King Lear"

Colleen E. Kennedy
Ohio State University

“Do You Smell a Fault?”:
Detecting and Deodorizing King Lear’s Distinctly Feminine Odor


1> In the very opening scene of William Shakespeare’s King Lear, the Dukes Gloucester and Kent discuss the conception and birth of Gloucester’s younger and illegitimate son, Edmund.

“Kent: Is this not your son, my lord?

Gloucester: His breeding, sir, hath been at my charge. I have so often blushed to acknowledge him that now I am brazed to it.

Kent: I cannot conceive.

Gloucester: Sir, this young fellow’s mother could, whereupon she grew round-wombed and had indeed, sir, a son for her cradle ere she had a husband for her bed. Do you smell a fault?

Kent: I cannot wish the fault undone, the issue of it being so proper.” (1.1.7-17)

In this opening passage, the sexualized and olfactory connotations of the term “fault” become obvious; beyond the more obvious meanings of ‘defect’ or ‘failing,’ “fault” is early modern slang for the female genitals and is a hunting term for a “break in the line of scent in hunting” (Astington 1985: 330-331). Edmund’s mother is reduced to whore, or as John Astington bluntly claims, “entirely impersonal cunt, attracting Gloucester as she might any man… through the scent of sex, like a bitch in heat” (1985: 333). Even as Gloucester displaces his own “fault” in his son’s conception, he implicates his son as shameful and asks Kent if he can still smell Edmund’s mother’s body (her “fault”), the sexual taint on his own flesh, on his son’s flesh, or even in the air. Gloucester is led by his nose; like a hunting dog, he becomes a smell-smock, an early modern term for womanizer, which creates the very literal image of a man sniffing at a woman’s skirts, and he asks Kent to participate in the same act of sniffing around for the scent of sex or the smell of the maternal body.[1]

2> The effluvia are gendered in this play as distinctly feminine, especially the noisome and noxious odors of the polluted or polluting female body, which calls for a recreation of the early modern Englishwoman’s aroma, and a study of the miasmic associations of this source of scent. All of the men in the play are affected by female bodies and smells, but this negative sniffing out of the feminine body is most apparent in the character of King Lear. Lear becomes emasculated, infantilized, and feminized throughout the play and this feminized version of his body is most obviously manifested in his admittance of his “mother.”[2] It is also perceptible, however, in Lear’s auto-parosmia, his illusion of smell, namely that the female body is fetid and that his own body is emitting the same offensive odor, a conflation of the odor di femmina and the odor mortis. Lear confuses and conflates his “essence,” his “being” or “existence,” with his “fragrant essence,” or “scent.”[3] Finally, once Lear detects his feminine odor, he goes about, with the help of Cordelia and the doctor, deodorizing this unpleasant scent, restoring himself back to his masculine and kingly state. Damning the feminine body and only sniffing out the negative miasmas, Lear finds the redemptive aromas of the feminine in Cordelia, but too late, contributing to both of their deaths.

3> Danielle Nagler in her very strong overview of the philosophies and controversies concerning smell in early modern England notes “King Lear contains more references to smell, its synonyms and cognates than any other of Shakespeare’s plays,” but “whilst there has been much debate over the relative importance of sight versus hearing in Shakespeare’s work, discussion of olfaction has been almost nonexistent” (Nagler 55, 43). The dismissal of the importance of smell should be obvious. The smell of the early modern body, especially the female body, is hard to denote in modern terms for many reasons: smell is ephemeral and difficult to identify and describe, and although the sense of smell is, of course, ubiquitous, it is dismissed at the same time, due to the problematic theories, philosophies, and controversies concerning smell from antiquity into the early Jacobean period (Palmer 62-63).


The Odor di Femmina

4> The female body, especially the maternal, in King Lear is “rank”; the fecund and fecal are conflated, so that the smells—pleasant and fetid—of fertility and the stench of death cannot be differentiated. As St. Augustine stated: “Inter urinas et faeces nascimur,” [“We are born between piss and shit].” Gail Kern Paster writes of the ambiguity surrounding the reproductive early modern female body: “Birth, like all events of the lower bodily stratum, has a larger part to play in the history of shame than in the history of representation” (163). For Paster, the bodies of reproductive women, whether the married wife or the wet-nurse, are both repellent and desirable, often at the same time. Much of this repulsion must do with the stenches associated with the process of birth. Paster describes some of the prevailing medical thoughts concerning the birthing byproducts: the afterbirth blood was useless, impure, foul, and stinking, and the smell of the nursing mother’s milk was considered repulsive to the husband (192-193, 204). In general, though blood was considered “laudable,” Paster asserts that this does not include womanly blood which was “demonized” (66). The female body, especially the reproductive body, was associated with flagrant stinks. Maybe Edgar, disguised as Tom Bedlam, should have claimed: “Fie, fo, and fum; I smell the blood of a British woman.”[4]

5> At the same time, the smells of the reproductive female body must be desirable, or there would be no smell-smocks like Gloucester sniffing around. Sex is bestial and dehumanizing in King Lear, and it is not associated with the more masculine sense of sight, but a base and feminine olfaction. This is why Edgar, disguised as Tom, claims that he “did the act of darkness” with his mistress; in the darkened bed, sight is naught, but all of the other senses, especially scent which lingers even after the act, are employed. This focus on sex and scent is apparent in Alain Corbin’s study of the fetishizing of early modern French women’s redolence: armpit sweat, worn undergarments, leather shoes, and bosom bouquets (45), but he notes “one strange silence, probably reflecting a taboo: these erotic writings make no allusion to the seductive power of vaginal odors except for a few references to menstruation” (45-46).[5]

6> In stark contrast, King Lear is a play with constant references to vaginal odors. We have already smelt the seductive power of Gloucester’s lover’s aroma; decades after impregnation, Gloucester still recalls her inviting smell. If the emanations of the early modern English woman’s body are problematic in that the potentially fertile body emits attractive scents and the recently sexualized body emits stench, the female body is dangerous because it functions like a poisonous flower: it draws the bee through its scent, the bee enters the flower, and then the bee leaves covered in the pollen on the way to the next flower, to further pollute and to become further polluted. The scent of the female body is intoxicating, but also polluting. Before we are born between piss and shit, we are also conceived there; so, before the stench of the mother’s body corrupts the child, the scent of the beloved’s body attracted her lover and attaches to him, altering his body as much as he has altered hers.

7> So, what did the early modern English woman smell like? I will attempt to offer a sniff into what real early modern Englishwomen smelled like. Firstly, we should consider early modern deodorization, the “removal of socially discreditable odors” (Largey and Watson 1027). Bathing was infrequent, as it was considered potentially harmful, but when one did partake in full-body immersion, the ritual was highly balsamic. The hands and face were probably cleansed with water daily, but the rest of the body infrequently. Queen Elizabeth I was considered extra-fastidious due to her monthly bathing ritual “whether she need it or no” (qtd. in Classen, Howes, and Synnott 71). Soap, made from fats and ashes, was not often used, but instead the body was given a dry rub with clean linen to remove dead skin, stale sweat, dirt, and other offensive particles (Cockayne 60).

8> In addition to the first step of deodorization, odorization, the “presentation of the self with accreditable odors through the ‘art’ of perfuming” would occur (Largey and Watson 1027). An augmentation of pleasing scents applied directly to the body enhanced the early modern Englishwoman’s desirability. The body was often perfumed with the then fashionable caprylic, or animal-based, odors: musk, civet, or ambergris, often compounded with other vegetable (flowers, spices, or herbs) accords. Ambergris, an excretory product of whales, has an “earthy” aroma “with seaweed qualities”; musk, secreted by deer, is described as “slightly ammoniacal”; and civet, from the anal glands of the civet cat, has a “disgusting odor, but when diluted it is very attractive” (Douek 223-224). Not only was the skin perfumed, but hair and cosmetics were also scented. Classen, Howes, and Synnott remind us of the ubiquity of early modern scented personal items—clothes, gloves, and even jewelry: “Not only would the body be perfumed, however, but virtually everything worn on the body as well” (72). The end result, due to natural bodily effluvia, strong animal-scented perfumes, and the plethora of aromatic materials would be overwhelming, and most likely offensive, to the modern nose. To the early modern male’s nose, however, feminine redolence is ambiguously regarded as it is both repulsive and attractive at once, and the threat of moral pollution and physical disease is always possible when one inhales.

9> Finally, there is one last, more imperceptible and even more intangible component of the smell of the early modern woman, the odor di femmina. Although the smell of the early modern woman changed after puberty and the associative discharge of menstrual blood, copulation truly enhanced or vitiated her scent. Femininity and female effluvia were most complete after sex; the male’s sperm, his aura seminalis, perfected the female’s aroma (Corbin 44-46).[6] Too much sex and sperm, however, could taint a woman’s natural humors and sexualized scent creating a smell of putrefaction (Corbin 46), the odor mortis.

10> But what should the early modern Englishwoman smell like? There are the idealizations of the female body as scented hortus conclusus—a fragrant, aromatic bower of bliss—the idyllic female body of Petrarchan poetry. For example, see Sir Edmund Spenser’s “Sonnet 64” (1595) in his Amoretti, for his comparison of the beloved’s body to a fragrant garden, where even normally inodorous body parts (eyes, brows, nipples) smell like bellamores, pinks, and jasmines. Yet the ideal hortus conclusus is entirely self-contained and impermeable; in this sense, the body should not let any emanation escape and the ideal female body would be inodorous. Michelle de Montaigne asserts this latter position in his essay “On Smells” when he writes on how women should smell: “Mulier tum bene olet, ubi nihil olet,” [“A woman has a good smell when she has no smell].” In a variant of “women should be seen and not heard,” Montaigne maintains that women should be inodorous: “A woman smells most perfectly when she does not smell at all, just as her deeds are said to smell sweeter when they are unnoticed and unheard” (134).

11> In the early modern period with its hygienic attitudes somewhere between lax and non-existent, the suppression of bodily odor was difficult, yet the obfuscation of malodor and the enhancement of pleasurable scents are denounced in many works. The use of perfume is considered deceitful, because it does not enhance natural scents, but deceptively attempts to obscure stench. This is the reason, Olfactus, the Sense of Smell, does not win the contest for supremacy of the Five Senses in Thomas Tomkis’s allegorical comedy Lingua (1607): “None can wear civet, but they are suspected of a proper bad scent” (4.3.49). It is this very deceptive and alluring combination of natural odors, perfumed clothing, and the aura seminalis that emanates from Goneril and Regan, but not from the inodorous Cordelia. Cordelia, unwilling to leave her father in her sisters’ care, states very early in the play that she can smell out both their treachery and their “faults” despite their elaborate, and most likely highly perfumed, gowns: “Time shall unfold what plighted cunning hides, who cover faults, at last with shame derides” (1.1.286-88). Cordelia differentiates herself from her sisters in her simplicity in speech, dress, and presumably smell. Much has made been made of the elaborate costuming of Goneril and Regan, but few have considered the olfactory dimensions of such dress—sewn-in sachets, pomanders, and the perfumes of the nobility—which would obscure the smell of disease and the aura seminalis associated with the evil sisters later in the play. Goneril and Regan’s “plighted cunning” seems to refer both to their promised lies to their father and their pleated dresses; the external deception of proper, aristocratic costuming, including cosmetics and perfumes, belies their internal deception of themselves as good daughters and faithful wives. The “plighted cunning” also has another implication of their pleated cunts, so that the ornate gowns both conceal and accentuate their “faults” simultaneously. Goneril and Regan emit a sexualized stench beneath their perfumed exteriors emanating from their “faults” that Lear will not “unfold” until much later in the play, but Cordelia, who remains inodorous throughout most of the play, can detect early on.

Sexual Stenches & the Reek of Disease

12> The very names of the two sisters marries together the imagery of the noble and the sexually diseased; Regan is a cognate of “queen,” while Goneril’s name recalls “gonorrhea,” the sexually transmitted disease, often conflated with syphilis, noted for its malodorous discharge (Adelman 298, n. 18). Goneril and Regan emit such sexualized and diseased stench throughout King Lear, but stench, no matter its source, in early modern beliefs is both physically and morally corruptible, and therefore, potentially deadly. Margaret Healey, writing on the spread of venereal disease and the plague in the early modern period notes, “You could be ‘touched’ in this period without being touched—without the mediation of the senses” (23). Healey ignores the olfactory implications of disease although many early modern writers realize that epidemic diseases come from one of two sources: contact or “contagion in the air” (Montaigne 135). Robert Burton notes that the nose is an “organ of health” and that “by avoiding bad smells, as by choosing good, which do as much alter and affect the body many times as diet itself” (I. 158). The close connection between the nose and the brain makes this sense more directly able to affect mood and overall well-being than the other senses (Palmer 63). Stench, in its deadly incarnations found in King Lear, whether the morbidific smell of decaying carcasses, the rank smell of the human body, or even the miasmic odor of wetlands and graveyards, is the smell of the sexual female body.

13> King Lear is strongly affected by his olfactory prowess, and his acute sense of smell affects his interactions with his daughters. Lear will wrongly associate morbidific and deceitful smells with his good daughter Cordelia, although her inodorous state differentiates her from her smelly sisters. When he renounces Cordelia after she fails his love-trial, he equates her to “the barbarous Scythian” (1.1.117). The Scythian is a loaded image in early modern works. The Scythian represents the foreign, the cruel, the unnatural, and was associated with both the ancient Amazon who defied social and sexual expectations and the more modern, unruly Irish (Roberts 101). The Scythian women, frightening in their matriarchal lifestyle and their ability to defeat men in battle, are according to Montaigne, also terrifyingly seductive with their perfumed and painted bodies (134-135). They are viragos in temperament, but they attempt to veil their masculine attributes beneath a feminine aura and aroma. At this point, this is how Lear feels about Cordelia. He feels betrayed; he believes his daughter is a cruel, unnatural “sometime daughter,” a “wretch whom Nature is ashamed almost to acknowledge hers” (1.1.120, 1.1.217-218). He can almost smell her treachery. There is a sort of vaguely sexualized stench Lear associates with Cordelia, possibly stemming from her assertion to share her love between her father and future husband. Lear, of course, is wrong about Cordelia; France, who will marry the disowned and dowerless daughter, realizes from the first that Cordelia is really the “balm of Lear’s age” (1.1.220).[7] Cordelia is not associated with the corrupt and corruptible stink of the sexualized and fertile female body, but rather, the restorative “balm” of medicinal aromatics and the redemptive aroma of sanctity. Lear eventually smells this out, but to late to save either of their lives.

14> Lear’s body slowly devolves throughout the play into an odoriferous feminine body, not the redemptive balm of Cordelia, but the putrescent, pathogenic bodies of Goneril and Regan. Lear’s body and his odor devolve because his body is in a liminal state; his is the body of the geriatric and the infant. The geriatric body and the infantile body are fungible in this tragedy, and Lear’s body vacillates between the two.[8] The infant is marked by his insistence on the supremacy of smell and touch over the other, less developed senses, and the geriatric usually suffers from presbyosmia, the loss of the olfactory senses with age, but Lear’s sense of smell is acute and guides him throughout the play. Lear tells Gloucester, “Thou knowest the first time that we smell air, we wail and cry” (4.6.178-180), but at eighty, Lear still finds himself smelling, wailing, and crying.

15> The two age extremes are also hard to differentiate from the feminine body in several respects. Firstly, the feminine body is a “grotesque” body, described by Gail Kern Paster as “open, permeable, effluent, leaky” as opposed to the masculine body—“whole, closed, opaque, self-contained,”—but “to be otherwise is both shameful and feminizing” (92). The geriatric and infantile bodies, like the feminine leaky vessel, are incontinent. No longer just born between piss and shit, these bodies are “at fault” with their own “faults,” defecating, urinating, drooling, and otherwise leaking inappropriately. For Lear, this incontinence most often manifests itself in his tears, “women’s weapons,” but also his inability to control the movements of his “mother” and his heart (2.4.119). Secondly, both bodies seem dependent on the female body, however grudgingly, as nurse or mother. Lear is initially upset with Cordelia for ruining his plans of setting his “rest on her kind nursery” as he “unburdened” of the crown and “all cares” could “crawl toward death” (1.1.124-125, 1.1.36-41). Goneril notes Lear’s dependence and his temper tantrums to her servant, Oswald: “Old fools are babes again, and must be used with checks as flatteries, when they are seen abused” (1.3.19-20). Finally, the bodies of old men, children, and especially women, are considered to be composed of cold and wet elements, as opposed to the hotter, drier constitutions of men, and are therefore linked to the foul odors and corruption associated with cold, damp, diseased places such as swamps and graveyards (Filipczak 22-23, Classen et al. 38, 49).[9]

16> Lear, caught in this liminal state, is now at the mercy of his two flattering daughters/mothers/nurses, Goneril and Regan, but he quickly realizes their deceitfulness. Lear anathematizes against both daughters, and he summons strong imagery with secondary olfactory implications that will later affect Lear’s perception of his own effluvium. Calling upon the goddess Nature, Lear invokes a curse of infertility and disease upon Goneril:

“Into her womb convey sterility;
Dry up in her the organ of increase,
And from her derogate body never spring
A babe to honor her.” (1.4.274-77)

Lear, deeming Goneril a cruel daughter, realizes that she would make a worse mother, so he appeals for his daughter’s defeminization, the curse of amenorrhea. By stopping up her menstrual blood, he is making her transformation into an unnatural monster complete. There were two competing theories of the need for menstruation in the early modern period that come from earlier physicians: purification, the purgation of improper humors (Hippocrates) and plethora, the “expelling of excess blood” (Galen) (Katz 442). Either way, a woman needed to expel the menstrual blood to avoid polluting her body. Helkiah Crooke, in his Microcosmographia, notes that although there is sufficient evidence to prove that menstrual blood is only “noisome excrement” and a “poyson” to the woman’s and others’ bodies, he believes that menstrual blood is, regardless of its noxious stench, natural and beneficial for the infant (289). This is because all the bodily fluids, including the breast milk for the infant, were reducible to blood.[10] Lear, stopping up Goneril’s blood, also stops up the release of menstrual odor. He denies her the natural smells of her own body, obscuring her “essence” as woman.

17> Lear asks the feminized and maternal Nature to do the unnatural and unmaternal by stopping Goneril’s menses. Lear’s malediction is almost verbatim the self-inflicted hex that Lady Macbeth insists upon in order to have the masculine qualities needed to murder Duncan. Jenijoy La Belle notes that the cancellation of her natural menstrual cycle, after she “unsexes” herself, is one of the factors that causes Lady Macbeth to go mad: “The smell of blood and the stains on her hands obsessively remind Lady Macbeth not only of Duncan’s spilled blood but also of that natural spillage of menstrual blood she has tried to prevent as a necessary prelude to the killing of a king” (385, my italics). Lady Macbeth is haunted by olfactory and visual hallucinations, but it is Lear, and not Goneril, who will suffer similar olfactory phantasms that are concentrated on the odor of the diseased, corrupting, and feminine body.

18> Lear continues his mephitic tirade against Goneril when he hopes that infectious vapors cause her to become lame and disfigured: “Strike her young bones, / You taking airs, with lameness./ … Infect her beauty, You fen-sucked fogs drawn by the pow’rful sun/ To fall and blast her pride” (2.4.160-162, 2.4.163-166). Here we can witness the pathogenic qualities of the air and how Lear links contagious disease, the beautifully seductive female body, and noxious stench. Lear, believing that Tom Bedlam must have been reduced to poverty by similarly horrible daughters, curses those nonexistent children: “Now all the plagues that in the pendulous air/ Hang fated o’er men’s faults fall on their daughters!” (3.4.68-69). In this line, the near homophones of “fault” and “fall” seem to recall the earlier pun on “faults” in Gloucester and Kent’s opening speech, implying that corruption is cyclical, but begins and ends with the stench of the female body. The absent mother’s body attracted the father through the smell of her “fault” and she was the site of original contagion. The father’s “fault” is both his mistake in conceiving the daughters and his own subsequently feminized, flawed body. The daughters’ “faults,” via their miasmas, further infect the father’s body. Finally, as punishment for this cyclic pollution, the air becomes infected with sexualized plague which will “fall” upon the daughters’ pathogenic bodies.

19> Lear does not just curse Goneril with disease, but Goneril also contaminates Lear. The diseased female body has infected his, but as Healey had stated about the spread of disease in this period, “You could be ‘touched’…without being touched” (23). Without sexual contact, Goneril has infected Lear, but the symptoms of the disease seem to evoke both syphilis/gonorrhea and the plague, diseases also contracted through smelling infected air:

“We’ll no more meet, no more see one another.
But yet thou art my flesh, my blood, my daughter,
Or rather a disease that lies in my flesh,
Which I must needs call mine. Thou art a boil,
A plague-sore, an embossed carbuncle
In my corrupted blood.” (2.4. 219-223)

Lear begins this diatribe by denying the supremacy of sight, and maybe also indicating the blindness associated with syphilis. This disease that is in his blood and flesh is not only in his body, it is his body; it is a grotesque, open, oozing, swollen body whose noxious and contagious stench reek of the odor mortis. His blood has been “corrupted” in an unspecified, though sexualized, way. These fetid symptoms conflate the plague and venereal disease, both considered to be transmitted through sexual touch and inhaled as noxious miasmas. Again, the site of contagion is unknown: Was it the deceased queen’s “fault” or the smell of Goneril’s pungent “fault” that has corrupted or reinfected Lear’s blood and body?

20> Boils, plague-sores, and carbuncles are automatically recognized by sight and touch, but even hidden beneath perfumed clothing (“plighted cunning”) these putrescent signifiers—the horrid stench of released pus and dead skin cells from an ulcerated boil, or the pong of malodorous sexual discharge—can also be smelt out as symptoms of plague and the pox. When Lear claims that Goneril is the cause of fetid malodor in his body, he has finally smelt out his daughters’ deception. Lear will state this directly when he encounters the blinded Gloucester: “I found them [out], there I smelt them [Goneril and Regan] out” (4.5. 100-102).[11] Lear can detect his own horrid stench that began with his daughters’ miasmas polluting his body.

21> When writing on the connection between all the olfactory images of rotting mortal flesh and the moral, political, familial, and sexual pollutions in Hamlet, Richard D. Altick notes that Shakespeare chooses the odor mortis because, “Every Elizabethan citizen knew from personal observation the reek of a gangrenous wound or a cancerous sore” (167). The smell of mortality is a signifier of physical and even spiritual corruption.[12] Lear, unlike Gloucester who denounces his culpability, incriminates himself when he refers to his own diseased and reeking body. And what does Lear’s body reek of? The putrescence of rotting flesh? The stench of death? The fetor of the female body? For Lear, all of these malodors are one and the same.

Lear’s Feminine Foulness

22> After Lear curses his daughters and believes he has been polluted by their distinctly feminized, sexualized miasmas, Goneril and Regan shut their father out of doors to deal with the feminine Mother Nature and her tempest. Lear, stripped of his kingly vestments and penetrated by the “sulphurous and thought-executing fires” of the storm, the inundations of rain, and his own feminine tears, stinks of the fecund and fecal mother Nature. Adelman writes on the androgynous nature of the storm, which at first seems male (the thunderer god), but also feminine (a witch’s storm), but in her estimation, “the very wetness of the storm comes to seem a sexual wetness” (112). Although Adelman does not mention this connection, this “sexual wetness” again links together female bodily effluvia, the cold-wet humors, the smell of sex, and the corrupting miasmas of disease. The storm is also “foul” in almost every sense of the word: grossly offensive to the senses of sight and smell, diseased, dirty, detestable, and morally and spiritually polluted.

23> Lear’s body is now the feminine grotesque body, penetrated by water, leaking water, and stinking of every corruptible and feminine stench. Instead of protecting his waning masculinity, Lear embraces his new, feminine odor. Replacing the crown that Lear has given away, Lear wanders the heath wearing a crown of his own design:

“Crowned with rank fumiter and furrow weeds,
With hardocks, hemlock, nettles, cuckooflowers,
Darnel, and all the idle weeds that grow
In our sustaining corn.” (4.4.3-6)

His crown is “rank,” “luxurious and vigorous in growth,” but also “having an offensively strong smell,” “corrupt, foul,” and “lustful, licentious” (OED), again relating the smells of corruption and fertility.[13] Philippa Berry notes that although all of the “‘weeds’ in Lear’s garland… seem to confirm a negative view of ‘waste,’ all those plants could be read as signs of fruitfulness, since they typically grow in moist and fertile ground; moreover, all were held to have some beneficial effects” (164). In addition to the confusion between fecundity and the fecal, most of these weeds can help with various female ailments and complaints.[14] Lear, unable to escape the redolence of the feminine body, has embraced this corruptive odor as his own stench, just as he admitted that Goneril was his flesh. Lear’s body smells of this cold, wet, diseased femaleness, or at least he believes so, to the point that he must wipe his hand before extending it to Gloucester, so as not to pollute his friend.

24> Although Lear has embraced this feminine and fetid odor, he still rails against it. This odor is him and not him at the same time; he has inhaled female stench, his wife’s body, his daughters’ “faults,” the cold-wet storm of Nature, but he insists he is “every inch a king,” not a polluted female body. Lear’s “essence,” his very “existence,” his “being,” is compromised because his “essence” is also his “perfume” or “scent” (OED). Because who we are and how we smell are fungible in King Lear, Lear must differentiate himself from his newly feminized scent. All of this vitriol toward the female body and its effluvia becomes most apparent in Lear’s most elaborate and extended speech on the corrupted female body.

25> Pointing to a phantom woman, most likely referring to Goneril, Lear states:

“… Behold yon simpering dame
Whose face between her forks presageth snow,
That minces virtue, and does shake the head
To hear of pleasure’s name:
The fitchew nor the soiled horse goes to’t
With a more riotous appetite. Down from the waist
They’re centaurs, though women all above;
But to the girdle do the gods inherit,
Beneath is all the fiend’s; there’s hell, there’s darkness,
There’s the sulphury pit, burning, scalding,
Stench, consumption. Fie, fie, fie; pah, pah!
Give me an ounce of civet, good apothecary,
To sweeten my imagination. There’s money for thee.

Gloucester: O, let me kiss that hand.

Lear: Here, wipe it first; it smells of mortality.” (4.6.118-133)

Lear, after all of the curses and repulsion aimed at his daughters’ sexualized and therefore pungent bodies, is haunted by a stinking and feminine hybrid. This imagined female marries together aspects of the mythic (centaurs), the divine (above the waist), the infernal (at the genitals and below), the bestial (the fitchew and the horse), and the monstrous (a face between the legs), and it all stinks.[15] Women play modest, but they are all really prostitutes. Twice Lear states this, in his reference to “fitchews”—polecats, a European skunk—and the “soiled horse.” “Fitchew” was a common early modern term for “prostitute,” linking together bodily, moral, and sexual corruption that can literally be smelt out. The prostitute’s attractive aura seminalis has been compromised by too much semen, creating a horrid stench instead. Both Diane Ackerman and Alain Corbin affirm that many Indo-European words for “prostitute” and any member of the skunk family are related, and both refer to the earlier root word for “rotting” (Ackerman 21). The “soiled horse” creates a homophonic pun between “horse” and “whores,” while “soiled,” according to the OED, can refer to a horse “fed with fresh-cut green fodder,” but the more common connotations of “defiled and dirtied” should also come to mind, creating the image of the lusty and irrational beast covered in its own feces and urine with flies flitting around the rump.

26> Writing on the pessimistic view of sex in King Lear, Robert H. West notes the distressed Lear’s belief that “sex is an insult to mankind and mercilessly alien—or that man is a beast” (56). As Alain Corbin explains, “Olfaction as the sense of lust, desire, and impulsiveness is associated with sensuality. Smelling and sniffing are associated with animal behavior” (6). The sense of smell and the smell of sex are not exclusive, but interconnected in early modern beliefs, and both are connected to a bestial nature. Danielle Nagler notes that in all of the inversions of authority and hierarchy in King Lear, that smell is the most important sense as “man must become animal to survive” (55). Gloucester is no longer the only smell-smock, but any man who engages in sex has been led by his nose and is no more than beast. Both men and women are implicated in the bestial degradation of sex. Whether we read “fitchew” and “soiled horse” as literal beasts or, respectively, “prostitute” and “dirty whores,” neither “go to’t”—Lear cannot even name the sexual act—“with a more riotous appetite” than the deceptively chaste woman. Here gustatory, olfactory, and tactile imagery is brought together in the image of a hedonistic orgy of sex and food.

27> The female body and its odors are dichotomized, insisting upon the earlier good-bad alignment of Cordelia versus her sisters. The female body is split in half—right at the “fault” line—at the “girdle,” the “waist,” the genitals. Lear has already admitted his own “fault” in disowning Cordelia: “O most small fault, how ugly didst thou in Cordelia show!” (1.4. 262-63). Cordelia’s “fault,” either her verbal blunder during the love-trial or her sexualized body, appears offensive at first, until Lear was able to compare her with his other daughters. The language of division and the bestial imagery continues with the mention of “centaurs,” traditionally half-man and half-horse known for their extreme lust. The very unnatural inversion of gender roles recalls Lear’s earlier connection between Cordelia and the Scythians/Amazons and recalls other Classical mythical female beasts—the mermaid, the siren, the harpy, etc, as well as early modern allegorical female villains, namely Spenser’s Error, while also anticipating Milton’s Sin. The rational and beautiful half, the upper torso, is “woman” possessed by the gods and may be associated with the divine and masculine sense of sight, but the lower half is bestial and demonic, belonging to the more sensual, feminine, and base senses of touch, taste, and especially smell.

28> Lear continues by moving away from pagan monsters to eternal spiritual and olfactory damnation: “There’s hell.” “Hell” is another loaded early modern term with religious, theatrical, sexual, and olfactory implications.[16] Hell is traditionally associated with horrid stenches, again, connecting moral and physical corruption with punishment. Dan Mackenzie notes that “smell” is related to a German dialect word for “hell,” smela, derived from an earlier word for “pitch” (73). “Hell” is also common early modern slang for female genitals and is invoked in Shakespeare’s “Sonnet 144” where the Dark Lady’s body is a polluting place that inflicts the youth’s and the poet’s bodies with venereal disease. The female body and sex, as stated earlier are not associated with sight, but with smell and touch; this is why this “hell” is a place of “darkness,” recalling Tom’s “act of darkness” with his imaginary mistress and anticipating Edgar’s final confrontation with his brother, referring to Edmund’s mother’s body as the “dark and vicious place” which “cost” Gloucester his eyes (5.3.174). The tactile and olfactory castigation in “hell,” whether the punishment of the Christian inferno or the regretful pain caused by contracting a sexually transmitted disease, is the same, as both involve “burning, scalding, stench, consumption.”[17] The stenches associated with the female body’s natural effluvia, sex, the open sores of syphilis, death, and eternal damnation are conflated and confused in Lear’s distracted mind, so much so, that he chokes on the noxious, and more importantly imaginary, miasma: “Fie, fie, fie; pah, pah!”

29> Lear demands “civet,” perfume created from cat secretion, from an invented “apothecary” to disguise the smells of the sexualized female body. Lear can no longer stand to smell the female body. The perfume must “sweeten his imagination.” Before Lear extolled Tom Bedlam as “unaccommodated man,” the very “thing itself,” the very essence of man, because Tom “ow’st the worm no silk… the cat no perfume” (3.4.107, 104-106). Lear, also semi-nude and removed from all the fineries and deceptions of the court—flattering daughters, rich silk gowns, and especially misleading perfumes—is not as lucky as the simple beggar because he cannot escape the stench of the female body, and now asks for the “civet” which he claimed as so deceptive earlier. There are no women present, but Lear smells this feminine stench on his own flesh. Since noxious odors are the cause of madness and the origin of contagious disease, the civet may act as a smell-trap, capturing the corruptible stink of the female body, or as a restorative aromatic, creating a stronger, competitive scent that erases the polluting stink. What is paradoxical about Lear’s insistence on civet is that these caprylic perfumes do not disguise natural body odors, but heighten the sexual smell because they smell the most like human sexual secretions (Ellis 97). After this diatribe, Gloucester recognizes his king, and Lear recognizes his own smell: the “smell of mortality,” the odor mortis, which for Lear is also the odor di femmina.

Deodorizing Lear’s Odor Mortis

30> Odors affect not only physical health, but also the mind and emotion, for good or ill. Lear, in his mad state, is rescued by Cordelia’s men, and now that he has detected a female stench on his body, he must be deodorized and then reodorized to be restored to a masculine, kingly state. Cordelia recognizes Lear’s stench as coming from his debased lodgings, but not necessarily from a feminine site of contagion: “Wast thou fain, poor father, to hovel thee with swine and rogues forlorn, in short and musty straw?” (4.7.39-41). Once in the care of Cordelia and her doctor, Lear is washed while sleeping.

31> Lear’s deodorization begins with the removal of his rank crown and wet rags, because as Robert Burton maintains, “Generally to fair nice pieces, old age and foul linen are two most odious things, a torment of torments” (I. 371). Lear’s bathing is most likely a dry cleansing involving clean linen, as “water not only corrupted the body, but physically corrupted it as well by rendering it moist and soft—feminine—and vulnerable to unhealthy air and disease” (Classen et al. 70). Lear’s body, already affected by the miasmas of the feminine Nature, the aspersion of the “sexualized wetness” of the storm and the petrichor of the heath, and the diseased, sexual stench of his daughters’ “faults,” cannot be made more wet or feminine without the potential to annihilate his masculinity. After bathing, the still slumbering Lear is put into “fresh garments,” maybe the fine attire of the king with all of its aromatic niceties (4.7.55-57). The doctor suggests “simple operatives” (4.4.14), herbal aromatics to restore Lear to his health and senses, and to remove the feminine reek of his rank crown.[18] Lear’s deodorization is so effective that he no longer recognizes his own hands (4.7.55), as they have been cleansed of the stench of mortality and the reek of sex.

32> After the process of detecting and deodorizing the feminine stench from Lear’s flesh, Cordelia calls for soothing music, and then when Lear wakes, the “balm” of his old age kisses her father. The breath emanating from her lips is medicinal, restoring Lear to his masculine, kingly state: “O my dear father, restoration hang thy medicine on my lips” (4.7.27-28). Although no odor of Cordelia is explicitly mentioned, the ancient “association of fragrance and kisses was part of a whole olfactory /amatory complex” (Classen et al. 27). In this belief, the soul, the breath, and the kiss were interchangeable, and Cordelia acknowledges this when she kisses her father. Cordelia is not associated with the sexualized, pathogenic miasmas of her sisters, but instead the restorative balms of medicine and the saintly aroma of sanctity. Cordelia, in her inodorous state, as opposed to the reeking stenches of her sisters, emits a subtle “aroma of sanctity,” the sweet scent associated with saints, martyrs, and Paradise, or the scent of funerary rites with the hope of “overcoming death, the promise of redemption, and the seemingly tangible connection with the spirit world” (Evans 196). This is exactly how Cordelia’s kiss functions in this scene. This is the moment that Lear is reborn, regains his sanity, redeems his relationship with his daughter, and reclaims his kinghood.

33> After her recuperative kiss, order is temporarily restored. Lear recognizes and greets his daughter: “For, as I am a man, I think this lady to be my child Cordelia” (4.7.71-72). Coppelia Kahn notes the importance of Lear’s proper use of the nouns “man,” lady,” and “child” as Lear realizing his role as father and king, or his acceptance of the intended familial, gendered, and intergenerational relationships he has subverted throughout (48). Threatened with imprisonment by Edmund, Lear remains in high spirits because of his reunion with Cordelia, but quickly reverts to his inversion of power dynamics: “Upon such sacrifices, my Cordelia, the gods themselves throw incense” (5.3.20-21). Incense, used in both pagan and Christian, especially Catholic, rituals ascertains the hierarchical relationship between the worlds of the divine and the mortal (Evans 194). But here, the order has been subverted, as Lear believes the gods will attempt to contact and appease him, instead of Lear expressing gratitude for the return and forgiveness of his daughter. Forgetting that these are the same gods who “kill us for their sport” (4.2.38), Lear’s speech is unintentionally hubristic, and the “sacrifices” will be Lear and Cordelia. Suzanne Evans states that “the scent of a martyr is not the scent of death, but the sweet smell of life” (208). Although this may be true in hagiographies, the same cannot be said for this tragedy. At the end of the play, the bodies of the dead fill the stage with the odor mortis. The smell-smock Gloucester dies; Edmund, born from his mother’s “fault” dies; the adulterous Goneril and cruel Regan die at each other’s hands; and Lear, hoping that Cordelia still lives, dies. Even Cordelia, the closest we have to a martyr, dies, leaving the stage littered with bodies and reeking of death, not the “sweet smell of life.”

34> Lear’s realization of the complete and myriad powers of the feminine body and its olfactory effects on the permeable masculine state comes much too late. Damning the feminine body and only sniffing out the negative miasmas, Lear finds the redemptive aromas of the feminine in Cordelia, but too late. In the final scene, Lear carries the hanged Cordelia onto the stage in an inversion of the pieta. He watches her lips for breath, obviously for a sign of life, but he may also be searching for her scent, as “breath” comes from the Old English word for “odor” (OED). Instead of denouncing female effluvia, whether emanating from Goneril and Regan, Mother Nature, or his own body, Lear is now searching frantically for this recuperative and redemptive aroma which no longer emanates from his daughter’s lips. Danielle Nagler reads Lear’s “smell of mortality” as the smell of truth, which “incorporates complete the smell of man” (58). What Nagler neglects is that in King Lear the smell of man, ultimately, is also the smell of woman. If Lear, now realizing his own inextricable place in the continuum of feminine odors, can no longer find Cordelia’s “essence,” her “scent” and her “existence,” he must also die because his own “essence” is lost.[19]

Works Cited

Ackerman, Diane. A Natural History of the Senses. New York: Random House, 1990.

Adelman, Janet. Suffocating Mothers: Fantasies of Maternal Origin in Shakespeare’s Plays, Hamlet to the Tempest. New York: Routledge, 1992.

Altick, Richard D. “Hamlet and the Odor of Mortality.” Shakespeare Quarterly 5.2 (Spring 1954):167-176.

Astington, John H. “‘Fault’ in Shakespeare.” Shakespeare Quarterly 36.3 (Aut. 1985): 330-334.

Berry, Philippa. Shakespeare’s Feminine Endings: Disfiguring Death in the Tragedies. London: Routledge, 1999.

Boyle, Robert. Essays of the Strange Subtility, Great Efficacy, and Determinate Nature of Effluviums. London: W.G. for M. Pitt, 1673. Folger Shakespeare Library.

Brathwayt, Richard. Essaies Upon the Five Senses, with a Pithie One Upon Distraction. London: 1620. Folger Shakespeare Library.

Burton, Robert. The Anatomy of Melancholy. Ed. Holbrook Jackson. New York: New York Review Books, 2001.

Classen, Constance, David Howes, and Anthony Synnott. Aroma: The Cultural History of Smell. London: Routledge, 1994.

Cockayne, Emily. Hubbub: Filth, Noise, & Stench in England 1600-1770. New Haven: Yale UP, 2007.

Corbin, Alain. The Foul and the Fragrant: Odor and the French Social Imagination. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1986.

Crooke, Helkiah. Microcosmographia: A Discription of the Body of Man Together with the Controversies Thereto Belonging. 2nd ed. London: Thomas & Richard Cotes, 1631. Folger Shakespeare Library.

Dodoens, Rembert. A New Herball, or Historie of Plants. Trans. Henrie Lyte. London: Edm. Bollisant, 1595. Folger Shakespeare Library.

Douek, Ellis. The Sense of Smell and its Abnormalities. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1974.

Evans, Suzanne. “The Scent of a Martyr.” Numen 49.2 (2002): 193-211.

Filipcazk, Zirka Z. Hot Dry Men, Cold Wet Woman: The Theory of Humors in Western Art 1575-1700. New York: The American Federation of the Arts, 1997.

Gerarde, John. The Herball or Generall Historie of Plants. London: John Norton, 1597. Folger Shakespeare Library.

Hall, John. Select Observations on English Bodies of Eminent Persons in Desperate Diseases. Trans. James Cook. London: Printed by H.H. & to be sold by Samuel Eddowes, 1683. Folger Shakespeare Library.

Harris, Jonathan Gil. “The Smell of Macbeth.” Shakespeare Quarterly 58.4 (Winter 2007): 465-486.

Havelock, Ellis. Studies in the Psychology of Sex. Vol. 2: Sexual Selection in Man and Sexual Inversion. New York: Random House, 1936.

Healey, Margaret. “Anxious and Fatal Contacts: Taming the Contagious Touch.” Sensible Flesh: On Touch and Culture in Early Modern Europe. Ed. Elizabeth D. Harvey. Philadelphia: U of Pennsylvania P, 2003: 22-38.

Kahn, Coppelia. “The Absent Mother in King Lear.” Rewriting the Renaissance: The Discourses of Sexual Difference in Early Modern Europe. Eds. Margaret W. Ferguson, Maureen Quilligan, and Nancy J. Vickers. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1986: 33-49.

Katz, David. S. “Shylock’s Gender: Jewish Male Menstruation in Early Modern England.” The Review of English Studies. New Series. 50.200 (Nov. 1999): 440-442.

Largey, Gale Peter and David Rodney Watson. “The Sociology of Odors.” The American Journal of Sociology. 77.6 (May 1972): 1021-1034.

La Belle, Jenijoy. “‘A Strange Infirmity’: Lady Macbeth’s Amenorrhea.” Shakespeare Quarterly. 31.3 (Autumn 1980): 381-386.

MacKenzie, Dan. Aromatics and the Soul: A Study of Smells. New York: Paul B. Hoeber, 1923.

Montaigne, Michelle de. “On Smells.” Essays. Trans. J.M. Cohen. London: Penguin, 1993.

Nagler, Danielle. “Towards the Smell of Mortality: Shakespeare and Ideas of Smell 1588-1625.” Cambridge Quarterly 26.1 (1997): 42-58.

Palmer, Richard. “In Bad Odour: Smell and its Significance in Medicine from Antiquity to the Seventeenth Century.” Medicine and the Five Senses. Ed. W.F. Bynum and Roy Porter. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1993: 61-68.

Paster, Gail Kern. The Body Embarrassed: Drama and the Discipline of Shame in Early Modern England. Ithaca, New York: Cornell UP, 1993.

Roberts, Jeanne Addison. The Shakespearean Wild: Geography, Genus, and Gender. Lincoln: U of Nebraska P, 1991.

Rudnytsky, Peter L. “‘The Dark and Vicious Place’: the Dread of the Vagina in King Lear.” Modern Philology 96.3 (Feb. 1999): 291-311.

Shakespeare, William. King Lear. A Conflated Text. Ed. Stephen Orgel. The Complete Pelican Shakespeare. Eds. Stephen Orgel and A.R. Braunmuller. New York: Penguin, 2002: 1573-1615.

Spenser, Edmund. “Sonnet 64.” Elizabethan Sonnets. Ed. Maurice Evans and Roy J. Booth. London: Phoenix, 2003: 131.

Tomkis, Thomas. Lingua: or the Combat of the Tongue, and the Five Senses for Superiority. A Pleasant Comedy. London, 1607. Old English Drama Students’ Facsimile Edition, 1913.

West, Robert H. “Sex and Pessimism in King Lear.” Shakespeare Quarterly 11.1 (Winter 1960): 55-60.

Notes:

1. “Smell-Smock.” OED. This term, used by Shakespeare’s contemporaries, Middleton and Heywood, denies the supremacy of sight in determining a sexual mate.

2. Coppelia Kahn writes of King Lear’s madness, especially his “hysterica passio,” as the result of his sense of loss of a mother; Kahn believes that Lear tries to make his daughters his mother to fill this void (40). Janet Adelman also believes that Lear must confront not only the “terrifying dependence on female forces outside himself, but also an equally terrifying femaleness within himself--a femaleness that he will come to call his ‘mother’” (104). I tend to agree with Adelman’s assertion more that this “hysteria” or “mother” is a manifestation of a gendered confusion.

3. “Essence” 1a. “Being, existence,” 3a. “Specific being, manner of existing, ‘what a thing is’; nature, character,” 10. “spec. A fragrant essence; a perfume, scent. Somewhat arch.” OED.

4. Edgar quotes from the old nursery rhyme: “Child Roland to the dark tower came, / His word was still “Fie, fo, and fum; / I smell the blood of a British man.” (3.4.184-186)

5. Ellis Havelock writes of the distinctive odors of menstruation. Besides the smell of menstrual blood, women’s breath may smell of chloroform or violets, and the body, especially the armpits, may exude a leathery scent, the smell of “sheep in rut,” ambergris, or violets (64, 80).

6. Ellis Havelock states that the seminal odor is often compared to a he-goat smell, and that the sexualized stench of a lecherous woman is likewise described as “hircine,” or goatish (64).

7. “Balm” is medicinal, but the OED’s initial definitions stress the aromatic qualities of the plant.

8. The similarity between the extremely young and old is probably best expressed in Jaques’ “All the world’s a stage” soliloquy from As You Like It; when discussing the very aged, Jacques states, “[The] last scene… is second childishness and mere oblivion, sans teeth, sans eyes, sans taste, sans everything” (2.7.162-165). In King Lear, there are several instances of this conflation of infant and senior; for example, when the Fool chides Lear for making his daughters his mother, giving them the rod, and pulling down his breeches (1.4.167-169).

9. Gail Kern Paster notes that the aged usually tend to be drier and contain less blood, which explains Lady Macbeth’s amazement at how much King Duncan bleeds (92). Leonard Lessius, a Jesuit physician, however, in his guide to prolonging life and health , believe that old men “grow dry and cold in excess” so “likewise they become full of moisture by reason of excremental humors” (150-151). For Lessius, coldness and moisture creates a cloudy, phlegmatic brain (82-83). Elderly men are able to be simultaneously wet and dry, but are almost always cold.

10. Paster notes that blood was the basis for semen, sweat, tears, milk, and all of other bodily fluids, and that all were relatively fungible (9).

11. See also Danielle Nagler on smelling out treachery and plots (43).

12. See also Coriolanus, where Martius curses the Romans with “boils and plagues” that can be smelt even before they are seen, and can infect purely through inhalations and without physical contact (1.4.30-34).

13. Richard Altick uses these variant definitions of “rank,” as both overly fertile and offensive to the nose, when writing on Hamlet’s description of Denmark as an “unweeded garden/ That grows to seed; things rank and gross in nature/ possess it merely” (173).

14. The feminine benefits of Lear’s garland include: reducing venereal disease (fumitory, nettles), either provoking menstruation or ceasing heavy periods (darnel, hardocks, nettles), aiding in conception (darnel), stopping the “whites” (hardocks), ending “green sickness” (cuckooflowers), and helping in an easier delivery (darnel).

The “whites” are any mucous discharge from the vagina, and “green sickness” or “chloris” is the anemia associated with younger women who have just started their menses (OED). The information about the medicinal properties of these plants comes from John Gerarde’s The Herball or Generall Historie of Plants (1597) and Rembert Dodoens’s A New Herball, or Historie of Plants (1595).

15. Peter Rudnytsky reads this face between the forks as the vagina dentata (304). For Rudnytsky, however, the nose is a vagina (299), Gloucester’s bleeding eye sockets are vaginas (293), and the mouth is vagina, so poor Gloucester ends up with four vaginas (two of which are menstruating)!

16. There is also the suggestion of the stage’s hell-mouth, which “probably emitted smoke and a hideous stench” during appropriate scenes (Harris 476). Harris, attempting to recapture “the smell of Macbeth,” describes the horrid odor of the fireworks used in the beginning to create the witches’ storm scene and its lingering effect on the stage, as well as the memory associations to the recent Gunpowder Plot. Possibly, the same effect may have occurred during the production of King Lear. Made mostly of dung and eggs, if used during the storm scene, the stench could still possibly be smelt in the theater at this point. Lear does use similar language for both the storm and the “hell,” as both stink of sulphur and both negatively affect his mind.

17. “Consumption,” the term used in 1623 Folio, connotes destruction, waste, and disease (OED). “Consummation,” the term used in the 1608 Quarto edition, (and my preference) implies the completion of marriage by the sexual act, or death (OED).

18. Aromatics were often used to treat hysterical fits in women, the “mother” Lear had complained of. In Galenic beliefs, the uterus could travel around the body, causing feelings of suffocation and hysteria if the womb moved too far up in the body. Although Helkiah Crooke denies that the uterus can really move or smell (the persistent Galenic belief), he does believe that it was much affected by the “subtile vapours” of any strong (pleasant or offensive) odor (252). Shakespeare’s son-in-law Dr. John Hall often used aromatic treatments for fits of the mother. He would burn fetid fumes--usually burnt horse hoofs, or castory (beaver musk) and galbanum (musky gum resin) dissolved in vinegar and sulphur—under the nose of a patient and anoint the “inner part of the matrix with musk, nutmeg, and lilies” (132). The combination of pleasant smells between the legs and fetid odors at the nose was supposed to lure the womb back to its proper place.

John Hall also used aromatics for men, such as a twenty-year old with “falling-sickness and hypochondriak melancholy” (23). Robert Boyle, in his Essays of the Strange Subtility, Great Efficacy, and Determinate Nature of Effluviums (1673), notes that although headaches and hysterical fits are often caused by “morbidifick odours” and victims are restored by “sal aromaniak” held beneath the nose, the aversion to strong odors does not affect the womb, but the “nervous system… because I have known Odours have notable effects even upon Men” (who also benefit from sal armoniak) (35-41).

19. “Essence” in the OED can mean one’s being or existence; one’s character or nature; or in an archaic definition: a “fragrant essence, perfume, or scent.”
_____

Colleen E. Kennedy is a PhD student in the English Department at the Ohio State University. She has her MA (English) and BA (English/Classics) from the University at Buffalo. Her research interests include early modern embodiment and sensory history of early modern drama and poetry. She is currently working on a project on the use of perfumes and incense in the early modern theatre.
_____

APPOSITIONS: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature & Culture, http://appositions.blogspot.com/, ISSN: 1946-1992, Volume Three (2010): Digital Archives