Book Reviewing in the Digital Age:
Practice/Politics/Pedagogy
Welcome to Event B at the Appositions 2009 conference, a forum for conversation about the topic of book reviewing in the digital age: practice/politics/pedagogy.
If you would like to participate, simply add your contribution here via the “post a comment” link at the bottom of this page.
A lively recent discussion in the public domain on the Milton-L listserv suggests that the subject of book reviewing in the field of Renaissance and early modern literary and cultural studies could benefit from renewed examination with regard to administrative and editorial best-practices, readerly and writerly concerns, professional development matters, and scholarly standards. To view the Milton-L December, 2008 Archives by thread, look for consecutive postings with “soliciting of reviews” and other related tags.
Administrative and editorial policies vary considerably from journal to journal (in print media) when it comes to how book reviews are managed from inquiry to process to production. Some journals (including RES) routinely send their book reviews out for peer-review; others (such as RQ) commission reviews; while other journals (like RELARTS) openly invite proposals for books to be reviewed.
A small number of those postings to Milton-L defended a conservative model: that, in most cases, bad books should be ignored; that reviews ought to be written by an inner-circle of established scholars; and that solicited book reviews should not be subject to peer-review.
How and why might electronic journals in the field solicit, evaluate, and produce book reviews of value? How and why might e-journals promote book reviews as vehicles for building new communities that either sustain or subvert the status quo?
We invite your comments, questions and statements toward a collaborative document on editorial and scholarly best practices for book reviewing in the digital age. _____
APPOSITIONS: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature & Culture, http://appositions.blogspot.com/, ISSN: 1946-1992, Volume Two (2009): Dialogues & Exchanges