Tuesday, May 31, 2011

David V. Urban: "Hopes for Milton Bibliography"

David V. Urban

Confessions of a Milton Bibliographer:
Reflections on the Past, Ruminations on the Present, and Hopes for the Future of Milton Bibliography

1> I am a dinosaur.  I have a bibliography forthcoming—IN PRINT.  The fact that I write these words for an online journal does not mitigate the veracity of my admission nor transform it into a charming paradox—it only disseminates the admission more rapidly.  What I mean to say, as I send off my freshly copyedited Milton bibliography manuscript to my editor, is that I recognize that I am perhaps the last of a dying breed, one that, if not utterly extinct, recognizes that it must give way to the inevitable mutability of a technology-driven future, a future that arrived some years ago while I strove to complete this project.  The project to which I refer is entitled, very simply, John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1989-1999, and it is scheduled for release by fall 2011.  It wasn’t originally my project; I inherited it, as it were, from a deceased scholar, Calvin Huckabay, by way of his editor, Paul J.  Klemp.  By accepting Klemp’s invitation to complete and edit Huckabay’s unfinished project, I embarked on a strange journey, both wonderful and tedious, which I will share in the ensuing pages.  My aim for this essay is to offer my reflections on that journey and, in the process, outline the history of Milton bibliography for the past eight decades, assess the current state of Milton bibliography, and consider possibilities for its future.*

2> My own involvement in this project can be traced to my appreciation for the work of earlier Milton bibliographers and their work’s tremendous aid to my early scholarship.  My story is as follows: I was early in my third year of my Ph.D., and my life was growing increasingly complicated.  Two years earlier I had entered doctoral studies at the comparatively mature age of thirty.  Married to a supportive but understandably concerned wife, having two masters degrees (I won’t go into that long story), eight years of teaching experience, and no children, I thought it prudent to finish my Ph.D. as expeditiously as possible to avoid excessive domestic and financial unrest.  To my eternal thanks, my ambitious plans stayed uncharacteristically on schedule, and although I was teaching two courses each semester, by May of my second year of doctoral studies I had completed my coursework, passed comprehensive exams (a milestone quickly followed by the discovery that my wife was pregnant with our first son), and had my dissertation prospectus approved.  During the ensuing months I began researching and writing with progressive urgency, baby Daniel was born, my wife lost her job, and I applied for forty-three professorial positions.  It was during this time that I began earnestly using Milton bibliographies.  The volume that my dissertation director specifically recommended to me was Huckabay and Klemp’s John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1968-1988, but because the annotations to that volume were quite short, I found myself particularly drawn to Klemp’s own bibliographies, The Essential Milton, and “Paradise Lost”: An Annotated Bibliography, both selective bibliographies whose annotations averaged roughly a hundred words.

3> Empowered by these reference works and Edward Jones’s Milton’s Sonnets: An Annotated Bibliography, 1900-1992, I researched and composed my dissertation.  My methodology was simple: Instead of allowing my analysis of Milton’s texts to be controlled by particular strong critical voices, I just wrote my own critical discussions as I thought best while using comparatively few secondary sources, read through the aforementioned bibliographies to find studies addressing similar works and issues, and then interacted with such studies as I revised my project.  Aided by these bibliographic resources, I was able to complete the dissertation in a year’s time, with my project even being my department’s nomination for the university-wide alumni dissertation award.

4> Early during that year of dissertation writing, I sent Paul Klemp a personal e-mail to thank him for his hard work and let him know how much his bibliographies were helping my own scholarship.  To my surprise, he quickly wrote back, genuinely thankful for my appreciation.  He also approved of my aforementioned method of using bibliographies to aid my scholarship and told me that he followed a similar method in his own critical writings.  We corresponded a few times after that, and during the summer after my dissertation defense, as my family and I prepared to depart for my tenure-track position at a small college in the Southwest, Professor Klemp called to inform me of Calvin Huckabay’s recent death, and, telling me that he believed I had “the mind of a bibliographer,” he offered me the task of completing and editing (the latter with his help) Huckabay’s unfinished bibliography.  Deeply moved, I gratefully accepted his offer. To my overly eager and genuinely naïve mind, my situation seemed ideal.  I would have the privilege of completing this important bibliography while simultaneously revising my dissertation into a book.  But completing Huckabay’s volume quickly proved challenging beyond my expectations, and I began to discover firsthand why the enterprise of bibliography is such a difficult one.

5> Before continuing to describe my own experience, I will briefly outline the history of Milton bibliography since 1930 and then explain why I consider Milton bibliography as we know it to be at a serious crossroads.1  I use 1930 as my starting point because that year saw the publication of David Harrison Stevens’ Reference Guide to Milton from 1800 to the Present Day.  That volume, just over three hundred pages in length, lists 2,850 items dating from 1800 to 1928, including editions of Milton’s writings, scholarly books, and articles arranged in numerous classifications.  Although it does not explicitly announce so, Stevens’ bibliography attempts comprehensiveness, although of course such comprehensiveness was (and remains) impossible to achieve.  Stevens’ omissions were duly noted, however, by Harris Francis Fletcher, who the following year came out with Contributions to a Milton Bibliography (1800-1930).  A slim volume roughly half the length of Stevens’, subtitled a List of Addenda to Stevens’ “Reference Guide to Milton,” Fletcher’s bibliography includes numerous items that Stevens missed, as well as items from 1929-1930.

6> Stevens’ and Fletcher’s annotations are noteworthy in a number of ways.  One is their brevity.  Stevens’ annotations are particularly short, often a mere ten words or fewer.  Moreover, Stevens’ and Fletcher’s brief annotations are often less descriptive than evaluative in nature, and some of these evaluations are downright caustic.  One in particular—Fletcher’s description of C. L. Barnes’ “Milton and Modern Science” as “fantastic and worthless” (122)—is explicitly mentioned in a review by the eminent Miltonist Denis Saurat.  Saurat questions the value of such an editorial approach for a bibliography, wishing instead for “more description and analysis” (413).  What Saurat considers most helpful is Fletcher’s practice of quoting salient sentences from particular works, something that Fletcher does fairly often, but by no means in the majority of his entries, and always without specifying the page number of the quotation. 2   But in general, neither Stevens nor Harris offers much more than a cursory description of most items.

7> The next major Milton bibliography to appear was Calvin Huckabay’s John Milton: A Bibliographical Supplement, 1929-1957.  Published in 1960, this bibliography includes nearly 2,000 items, following Stevens’ basic classifications and attempting comprehensive coverage while acknowledging the impossibility of such an enterprise.  Huckabay’s items are even more sparsely annotated than Stevens’ and Fletcher’s, with the vast majority of his entries containing no annotations at all and the others receiving a single—generally very short—sentence of summary.   A very few items contain two sentences of summary.  Only rarely does Huckabay quote from any of the studies that he lists.  Unlike Stevens’ and Fletcher’s bibliographies, Huckabay’s volume avoids judgment on the value of the items listed.  In 1969 Huckabay published a significantly updated volume, John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1929-1968.   This volume contains twice as many entries as its earlier incarnation.  Moreover, its annotations, while still relatively brief, are in general more substantive than those in Huckabay’s original bibliography.  The majority of items receive some annotation, and although annotations more than a sentence remain a rarity, the single-sentence summaries are noticeably longer.  Moreover, Huckabay quotes considerably more frequently from the items he annotates.  Throughout this updated volume, Huckabay continues to refrain from judgmental commentary in his annotations.

8> The next major Milton bibliography to appear was C. A. Patrides’ 1987 effort, An Annotated Critical Biography of John Milton.  Unlike the efforts of Stevens, Fletcher, and Huckabay, Patrides’ bibliography is self-consciously selective, containing 1,145 items, most published from the 1940s into the 1980s.  Many items contain no annotations at all, and the annotations that appear are strikingly brief—often a mere sentence fragment—and often containing Patrides’ explicit endorsement or lack thereof.

9> Whatever the differences between the bibliographies discussed above, the most noticeable common element between them is, regrettably, the extreme brevity of their annotations.  I call such brevity regrettable because, although offering short annotations is less labor intensive and conducive to timely publication, it prevents readers of these bibliographies, whether they use them to assist their own research or simply to gain a greater understanding of the field of Milton studies, from gaining any substantive understanding of the contents of the listed items much beyond that which a title might indicate.   With the stature and scope of the MLA International Bibliography—despite its considerable limitations3 —continuing to increase since its 1921 inception, not to mention lists of publications available through the OCLC network, any Milton-specific bibliography with minimal annotations would have a harder time justifying its independent existence.

10> It should be noted, however, that the minimalist efforts of Milton bibliographers through the late 1980s were not always duplicated by bibliographers of related authors.  In 1973, John R. Roberts’ John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1912-1967 appeared.  Roberts’ volume is remarkable both for its comprehensive coverage and for substantive annotations, which dwarf those offered in any of the aforementioned Milton bibliographies.  Moreover, this volume was followed by Roberts’ 1982 effort, John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1968-1978, another comprehensive effort containing even more substantive annotations.  And since the 1960s, Shakespeare Quarterly had been publishing its annual bibliography issue, volumes whose immense number of items often precluded substantive annotations but were nonetheless highly laudable for their thoroughness and yearly appearances.  These volumes were eventually replaced by Shakespeare Quarterly’s World Shakespeare Bibliography Online, an extraordinary enterprise I shall discuss further later in this essay.

11> Whatever Roberts’ accomplishments in Donne bibliography, substantive annotations within Milton bibliographies did not appear until the 1989 publication of Paul J. Klemp’s The Essential Milton: An Annotated Bibliography of Major Modern Studies, a book that followed on the heels of Larry S. Champion’s The Essential Shakespeare: An Annotated Bibliography of Major Modern Studies (1986).  A selective bibliography of 1,021 studies published between 1900 and 1987, Klemp’s volume contains thorough annotations of roughly 100 words each, often including significant quotations from listed items.  Klemp follows a similar format in his 1996 effort, “Paradise Lost”: An Annotated Bibliography, which annotates 450 selected studies from the 20th century, emphasizing works from 1967 to 1995.  In between the publication of Klemp’s bibliographies appeared Edward Jones’ Milton’s Sonnets: An Annotated Bibliography, 1900-1992 (1994), another impressive effort that offered 516 substantive annotations, attempting comprehensiveness in its coverage of scholarship on this select group of Milton’s writings.

12> To be sure, Klemp’s and Jones’ aforementioned volumes represented significant forward progress in the field of Milton bibliography.  As a Milton scholar—and perhaps more significantly, as a one-time Milton dissertation writer—I can testify firsthand to their immense helpfulness to those who desire to better understand the sweep of Milton scholarship that these volumes cover and to employ such scholarship in their own work.  But there still remained no Milton bibliography that combined comprehensive coverage with thorough annotations.  Huckabay’s next volume (edited by Klemp), John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1968-1988 (1996), was comprehensive in scope but, although its annotations were longer than Huckabay’s earlier efforts, they cannot be considered particularly thorough, being noticeably less substantive than those of Klemp’s and Jones’ volumes or of Roberts’ Donne bibliographies.  Indeed, the contrast between Huckabay’s annotations and Roberts’ became even more pronounced upon the 2004 publication of Roberts’ magisterial John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1979-1995.

13> When I accepted the invitation to complete and edit Huckabay’s final bibliography, I purposed to have the volume exhibit both the comprehensive scope of Huckabay’s earlier volumes and the kind of substantive annotations seen in Klemp’s and Jones’ bibliographies.  This meant checking the veracity of and significantly extending the vast majority of Huckabay’s existing annotations, as well as adding several hundred new items.  But in the painfully slow course of accomplishing these goals, I discovered what an arduous enterprise bibliography can be, and my discoveries have convinced me that the whole field of Milton bibliography needs to change its approach for future projects.  The very nuts and bolts of my job were highly problematic throughout.  One problem was that I had to check the thousands of quotations in the existing manuscript, but the manuscript didn’t include the page numbers to the quotations.  But perhaps the largest problem was that my first professorial job was at a very small school with a very small library, a significant distance away from the nearest major university library.  I still remember my first—and last—conversation about the bibliography with the director of our library.  When I asked him if the library subscribed to Milton Quarterly or Milton Studies, he was flabbergasted, even aghast.  “Those journals are very specialized, very specialized,” he said.  He also informed me that interlibrary loan requests needed to be moderate in number.  And very early into our discussion, he spoke the dreaded sentence:  “This isn’t a research university.”   And indeed it isn’t, and neither are many, many other schools—often, like my former institution, schools that offer an excellent undergraduate education—where potential bibliographers might work.  But the fact of the matter is that any scholar attempting to compile a comprehensive annotated bibliography needs access to numerous journals and books and almost certainly needs the aid of a truly indefatigable and longsuffering interlibrary loan librarian.  It also helps tremendously to have paid students and/or secretaries who can devote substantial time to assist one’s research.  And the vast majority of small colleges simply don’t offer such resources.  It was not until I moved to a more research-friendly institution two years later that I was able to make any significant progress on the bibliography.4

14> So perhaps the answer is that all bibliographers should work at research institutions, but there is a major caveat to this solution, because English departments at research institutions are often less than sanguine about giving tenure and promotion for bibliography projects.  And then there is the related matter that bibliographers, particularly those with junior faculty status, need to simultaneously work on other projects—usually traditional scholarly articles—if they are going to have anything to show for themselves besides a bibliography “in progress.”  Compiling a bibliography is a slow, arduous process, and if one is working on a large, well-annotated, comprehensive project, one cannot guarantee that it will be completed in time for one’s inevitable day of institutional judgment.

15> For me, pursuing bibliography has proven a double-edged sword professionally.  Positive aspects include my wide exposure to every kind of Milton scholarship from around the world. I have gained a deep respect for the work of many scholars, and I have developed a special appreciation for scholars whose efforts display the marked erudition of those who have quietly cultivated their craft as Miltonists, including those whose high quality of scholarship is not matched by their prominence in the field.  And I have the satisfaction of knowing that I have helped to produce, however tardy my efforts, the first Milton bibliography that offers both the comprehensive scope and thorough annotations seen in Roberts’ Donne volumes.  At the same time, work on this project has come at the cost of my own monograph’s prompt completion.  There is a certain irony in the fact that the dissertation that was swiftly completed with the aid of Milton bibliographies has had its revision into book form seriously delayed by my commitment to completing Huckabay’s final bibliography.  Sometimes in morbid moments of self pity, I apply Milton’s Sonnet 7 to my own situation, envisioning the scholars who finished their dissertations at roughly the same time as I but who have years ago published those dissertations as books as the equivalent of the “more timely-happy spirits” to whom Milton compared himself.

16> Having said that, I continue to believe in the value of annotated bibliography and of comprehensive bibliography in particular.  There is something truly wonderful about discovering for oneself and then giving broader exposure to quality scholarship published in less prestigious and/or less widely distributed venues.  But I also increasingly believe that significant bibliography projects should not be undertaken by one compiler alone, even if that compiler has an editor who assists him or her at various stages of the project.  Rather, I propose that future Milton bibliography projects be divided among a group of scholars, each of whom is responsible for a particular portion of the whole, under the leadership of two or three main editors.  In the model I envision, the bibliography could be completed in a manner similar to a collection of scholarly essays.  Such a collaborative model would make for more efficient project completion and would offer bibliographers the kind of camaraderie and resource sharing that would mitigate against isolation and discouragement and promote productivity and excellence.  Moreover, the ever-developing resources of the internet can allow for Milton bibliography, at a central online site, to be an ongoing project, one that begins its coverage of scholarship at the year 2000 and continues indefinitely with the aid of various contributors, under the ongoing guidance of two or three main editors.

17> Opportunities for doing bibliography on the web are especially important for Miltonists to consider because bibliography in general, and Milton bibliography in particular, is facing the painful reality that libraries simply are not buying bibliography-related volumes at the rate they once did.  An unfortunate example of this trend is seen in the sadly disappointing sales of Roberts’ 2004 Donne bibliography (Wadsworth-Booth), a work that is probably the most remarkably thorough single-volume literary bibliography I have ever seen and the winner of the John Donne Society’s award for the most distinguished book in Donne studies for that year.  As a consequence of such disappointing sales, it is becoming increasingly unprofitable for academic publishers to come out with new bibliographies.

18> I encountered this sad reality firsthand when, having completed the John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1989-1999 a year before my upcoming tenure decision, I was informed that Duquesne University Press would probably not be able to publish this volume without significant outside support.  Indeed, financial concerns, along with concerns about the overall viability of publishing a bibliography project in light of the other early modern projects the press was considering, contributed to a substantial delay in the publication of the volume.  Thankfully—very thankfully—financial support surfaced from a generous subvention grant from Calvin College’s Calvin Center for Christian Scholarship; in addition, Duquesne University Press plans to publish the bibliography as an e-book in early 2012 as part of the University Press Content Consortium, which will more widely disseminate the work and also provide additional income from the investment in this project. But as grateful as I am for these developments, such support or partnerships simply cannot be assumed for future bibliographic endeavors.  And it seems clear that future bibliography volumes will almost certainly not be disseminated as print books.  We Miltonists should ask ourselves: How shall we pursue bibliography in the future?

19> From my perspective, Miltonists have several possibilities, each of which is currently being used by scholars of Milton, Shakespeare, or Donne.  I will discuss them in ascending order from what I consider the least to the most attractive options.

20> The first possibility is simply to jettison the idea of comprehensive annotated bibliography altogether.  We could simply satisfy ourselves with Milton Quarterly’s summaries of select recent articles, and rely on the MLA International Bibliography, references in other scholarship, and perusal of particular journals and books to alert us to other promising work, sans annotations.  At the present, this seems to be Milton scholarship’s default position.  As far as I know, there is no current attempt being made to comprehensively or even broadly annotate Milton scholarship beyond 1999.  Such bibliographic inertia, I suggest, will result in a kind of scholarly elitism in which, with occasional exceptions, only the best-known forums for Milton scholarship are consulted by scholars and students.  The net effect will be a more pronounced neglect of Milton scholarship published in lesser-known venues and an overall slowing of momentum in Milton scholarship as a whole. Clearly this current state of affairs is unacceptable and should be addressed.

21> The second possibility is to continue the existing model of compiling comprehensive Milton bibliography: Miltonists could enlist another individual or two to begin compiling a new Milton bibliography beginning at 2000 and pursue the possibility of Duquesne University Press or some other publisher teaming up with an electronic aggregator to try to publish such a volume in a dual print/e-book format or simply as an e-book.  But this approach has serious drawbacks.   Significantly, it appears that Duquesne sees the financial writing on the wall and will likely let John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1989-1999 be its final bibliography, at least in the field of Early Modern studies.  Already many other publishers—the University of Pittsburgh Press, the University of Missouri Press, and others—have long since abandoned the publication of print bibliographies.  Even if the prognosis for publishing future bibliographies in book/e-book form is less doubtful than what I suggest here, any Milton bibliographer taking the traditional book or even e-book route must have sufficient institutional support to even consider such a commitment, lest market realities render his or her efforts unpublishable.   Moreover, publication of future Milton bibliographies in book form will assure that the lag time between bibliography publication and the works such a future bibliography annotates will continue to be regrettably pronounced.

22> A third possibility is to try to follow the model of the World Shakespeare Bibliography Online, an ongoing project, stunning in its comprehensive scope, thorough annotations, and up-to-date coverage.  This project, long connected to Shakespeare Quarterly, is published by Johns Hopkins University Press, maintained by Project Muse, and centered at Texas A&M University, where the entire enterprise is overseen by the venerable bibliographer James Harner.  But it is not realistic for the field of Milton bibliography to be able to duplicate the efforts of the WSBO—which currently contains over 127,500 annotated entries covering “Shakespeare-related scholarship and theatrical productions published or produced worldwide between 1960 and 2011” (Harner, World)5—anytime soon.  Significantly, the WSBO has been operating since 2000, representing the truly magnificent fruit of Shakespeare Quarterly’s five-decade commitment to publishing a comprehensive annual annotated bibliography.  Also, because of continued funding through the Folger Shakespeare Library, the WSBO also has expert, full-time staffing that far exceeds what Milton bibliography’s resources can provide in the foreseeable future.

23> A final, and I think the best, option for future Milton bibliography efforts would resemble the model being used by the distinguished website Digital Donne: The Online Variorum.  Remarkably, Digital Donne, through downloadable PDF files, gives free access to all three of Roberts’ aforementioned Donne bibliographies, having received permission to offer these resources from those volumes’ respective publishers, the University of Missouri Press and Duquesne University Press.   Moreover, Digital Donne also offers an additional Roberts volume, John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1996-2005.6  This 2011 volume is every bit as thorough as Roberts’ 2004 effort, but because of the previously discussed market realities, Roberts was not able to find a traditional university press publisher for this bibliography.  Consequently, Roberts published it directly on Digital Donne.  According to Digital Donne’s current president, Gary Stringer, Roberts is likely to publish additions to the latest bibliography on Digital Donne in one-, two-, or three-year increments, thus providing quicker access to his work than was possible when the constraints of print publication dictated waiting until he had in hand a quantity of material sufficient to justify publication of a book.  And, says Stringer, at some point in the future, Roberts’ efforts may well be carried on as a collaborative effort by a committee of Donne scholars who will work to keep the bibliography updated on Digital Donne.  Stringer also emphasizes the long-term affordability of maintaining such a web presence.  If the website is well run and based with a stable server, he assures me, the cost of keeping large documents on that site are comparatively negligible.

24> It seems clear to me that the time is right for Milton bibliography to establish a significant online presence.  The Milton Society of America’s internet-savvy new Secretary, Ken Hiltner of the University of California at Santa Barbara, has recently designed the MSA’s first website, and he and the MSA Executive Committee are open to using the MSA website to publish new bibliographic materials (Hiltner, “Milton”).  Clearly Milton studies does not have a dominant single bibliographer analogous to what the great John R. Roberts is to Donne studies.  But we do have a number of accomplished bibliographers who could oversee a collaborative online effort for future Milton bibliography.  In a recent conversation, Hiltner and I discussed the idea of an ongoing bibliography of scholarship dating from 2000 onwards on the MSA website, a bibliography that would accept bibliographic entries from a wide group of approved scholars and graduate students, overseen by several senior bibliographers.  Instead of waiting for a completed bibliography volume to post such annotations, the annotations could be posted as they are submitted and accepted, and thus be of immediate use to other scholars and offer contributing bibliographers the valuable satisfaction of seeing their work published in a gratifyingly timely manner—something that, I should add, would be an impetus for scholars to regularly contribute valuable annotated items to such an ongoing project.  Substantial contributions to this project could both serve as a way to initiate graduate students into the realm of professional Milton studies (and increase their subsequent marketability) and serve as a valuable portion of a tenure-track faculty member’s larger tenure portfolio, allowing the faculty member to demonstrate published accomplishment in the genre of bibliography without relying unduly upon bibliography for his or her tenure and promotion.

25> The MSA website could also imitate Digital Donne by securing permission from publishers to post older Milton bibliographies that are now out of print.  Given Digital Donne’s success in posting Roberts’ earlier volumes, it seems likely that the MSA would be granted similar permissions.  Stringer, who is also a longstanding member of the MSA, made clear to me that he and others running Digital Donne would be happy to assist the MSA in such efforts by sharing relevant electronic resources and expertise.

26> It is ironic to consider that in his 1931 bibliography, Fletcher envisioned overseeing an enterprise in which the larger Milton scholarly community would produce future Milton bibliographies rapidly, over five year intervals (6).  Obviously Fletcher’s collaborative vision never came to fruition, but eighty years later, it seems clear that the time for such collaborative bibliography has arrived.7  With the recent March passing of John T. Shawcross and the untimely 2009 death of Albert C. Labriola, the longstanding MSA Secretary, Milton Studies editor, and Duquesne University Press’ Medieval & Renaissance Literary Studies editor, Milton studies as a whole is presently in a state of transition.  It seems to me that one of the best ways current Milton scholars can honor the memory of these forerunners is for us to make fuller use of the electronic resources before us.  I believe that developing Milton bibliography online through collaborative efforts is one of the most significant ways Milton scholarship can move forward in the days ahead.

Notes:

*I would like to thank James Harner (Editor, World Shakespeare Bibliography Online) Ken Hiltner (Secretary, Milton Society of America), Gary Stringer (President, Digital Donne) and Susan Wadsworth-Booth (Director, Duquesne University Press) both for granting me telephone interviews and for checking my essay to ensure that I represented our respective interviews accurately.  Thanks also to Brian D. Ingraffia, Paul J. Klemp, and Dean Ward for their valuable comments on earlier versions of this essay.  And a special thanks to Susan Felch and the Calvin Center for Christian Scholarship, whose support of my forthcoming Milton bibliography helped make this essay possible.
 
1. In the ensuing discussion, I intentionally omit discussion of John T. Shawcross’ excellent bibliographic work on 17th century documents related to Milton because it does not represent the kind of annotated bibliography of 19th and especially 20th century editions and scholarship on Milton discussed in this essay.
 
2. Of the other bibliographies I discuss in this essay, those of Champion, Jones, Klemp, Roberts, and Huckabay/Urban/Klemp include page numbers for their quotations.  The other Huckabay volumes as well as the bibliographies of Patrides and Harner (WSBO) do not give page numbers for quotations.
 
3. For a discussion of the limits of the scope of the MLA International Bibliography, see Harner, “Some Suggestions.”  From the perspective of Milton studies, a rather stark example of the MLA International Bibliography’s limitations is its continued omission of Pruitt and Durham’s Milton’s Legacy, a volume that was awarded the Milton Society of America’s Irene Samuel Memorial Award for the best multi-author collection published in 2005.
 
4. Significantly, although Huckabay worked at the comparatively small Houston Baptist University, he conducted most of his research at nearby Rice University’s world-class Fondren Library.
 
5. In a recent telephone conversation, Harner noted that since the WSBO began in 2000, its annotations have become considerably more thorough than what they were when the annual Shakespeare bibliography still appeared in print as a yearly issue of Shakespeare Quarterly.
 
6. Roberts’ four Donne bibliographies can be found on the website Digital Donne under the “Resources” link.
 
7. In our March conversation, Hiltner mentioned that at the University of California at Santa Barbara’s Early Modern Center’s recent conference, “The Future of Literary Studies, 1500-1800,” there was a general consensus affirming that future Early Modern literary studies will be increasingly collaborative in nature.
 
Works Cited:
 
Barnes, C. L.  “Milton and Modern Science.”  Nature 121 (1928): 831.
 
Champion, Larry S.  The Essential Shakespeare: An Annotated Bibliography of Major Modern Studies.  Boston: Hall, 1986.
 
Fletcher, Harris Francis.  Contributions to a Milton Bibliography, 1800-1930: Being a List of Addenda to Stevens’s “Reference Guide to Milton.”  University of Illinois Studies in Language and Literature 16.  Urbana: U of Illinois Press, 1931.
 
Harner, James L.  Telephone interview.  24 Mar.  2011.
 
---.  “Some Suggestions for the Future of the MLA International Bibliography.”  Bibliography in Literature, Folklore, Language and Linguistics.  Ed. David William Foster and James R. Kelly.  Jefferson, NC: McFarland, 2003.  153-60.
 
---.  World Shakespeare Bibliography Online.  Johns Hopkins UP, 2011.  Web. 19 Apr. 2011.
 
Hiltner, Ken.  “Milton Bibliography.”  Message to the author.  3 Apr. 2011.  E-mail.
 
---.  Telephone interview.  29 Mar. 2011.
 
Huckabay, Calvin.  John Milton: A Bibliographical Supplement, 1929-1957.  Pittsburgh: Duquesne UP, 1960.
 
---.  John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1929-1968.  Pittsburgh: Duquesne UP, 1969.
 
---.  John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1968-1988.  Ed. Paul J. Klemp.  Pittsburgh: Duquesne UP, 1996.
 
---.  and David V. Urban.  John Milton: An Annotated Bibliography, 1989-1999.  Ed. David V. Urban and Paul J. Klemp.  Pittsburgh: Duquesne UP, 2011 (forthcoming).
 
Jones, Edward.  Milton’s Sonnets: An Annotated Bibliography, 1900-1992.  Binghamton, NY: Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, 1994.
 
Klemp, P. J.  The Essential Milton: An Annotated Bibliography of Major Modern Studies.  Boston: Hall, 1989.
 
Klemp, Paul J.  “Paradise Lost”: An Annotated Bibliography.  Lantham, MD: Scarecrow Press, 1996.
 
MLA International Bibliography.  New York: Modern Languages Association, 2011.  Web. 25 Apr. 2011.
 
Patrides, C. A.  An Annotated Critical Bibliography of John Milton.  New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1987.
 
Pruitt, Kristen A. and Charles W. Durham, eds.  Milton’s Legacy.  Selinsgrove, PA: Susquehanna UP; Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses, 2005.
 
Roberts, John R.  John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1912-1967.  Colombia: U of Missouri Press, 1973.  Available as a PDF at Digital Donne.
 
---.  John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1968-1978.  Colombia: U of Missouri Press, 1982.  Available as a PDF at Digital Donne.
 
---.  John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1979-1996.  Pittsburgh: Duquesne UP, 2005.  Available as a PDF at Digital Donne.
 
---.  John Donne: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1996-2005.  Digital Donne, 2011.
 
Saurat, Denis.  Rev. of Harris Francis Fletcher, Contributions to a Milton Bibliography (1800-1930).  Modern Language Notes 48 (1933): 413-14.
 
Shawcross, John T.  Milton: A Bibliography for the Years 1624-1700.  Binghamton, NY: Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, 1984.
 
Stevens, David Harrison.  Reference Guide to Milton: From 1800 to the Present Day.  Chicago: U of Chicago Press, 1930.
 
Stringer, Gary.  Telephone interview.  25 Mar. 2011.
 
Wadsworth-Booth, Susan.  Telephone interview.  31 Mar. 2011.
_____

David V. Urban is associate professor of English at Calvin College.  He is the co-editor of Visionary Milton, and his most recent articles on Milton appear in Milton Studies and Milton Quarterly.  He has also recently published essays on Fugard and Tolstoy and Pauline rhetoric.  He is completing a book on Milton and Jesus’ parables.  His most recent reviews appear in the Review of English Studies and Early Modern Literary Studies.  He can be reached at dvu2@calvin.edu.
_____

APPOSITIONS:
Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern
Literature & Culture,
ISSN: 1946-1992,
Volume Four (2011): Texts & Contexts

_____

* * * REVIEW * * *

Anne Greenfield: “Women, Murder & Equity”

Anne Greenfield

Book Review

Randall Martin, Women, Murder, and Equity in Early Modern England.  Routledge (New York, 2008), 288 pp. + xii.  ISBN (10): 0-415-96115-7.  ISBN (13): 978-0-415-96115-8.  $125.00 (USD).

1> Randall Martin’s Women, Murder, and Equity in Early Modern England offers a comprehensive analysis of female homicide as it was represented in printed crime news from 1573 to 1697. The emergence and growth of print journalism in the seventeenth century meant that Early Modern readers learned about murderesses from a variety of news genres and authorial perspectives. As Martin convincingly argues, this diversity of interpretation opened a space for readers to question official court decisions, to weigh evidence (and sources for evidence) critically, and—most importantly—to sympathize with murderesses to a degree unprecedented in English history.

2> The first of Martin’s five chapters contextualizes the theoretical underpinnings of the study, the climate and procedures of Early Modern trials for female homicide, and the production and circulation of crime news at that time. As Martin explains, female capital offenders had little opportunity to rebut the charges against them. Without defense attorneys, without the right to claim the benefit of clergy, and with no initial presumption of innocence, women accused of murder possessed little agency in crafting their own defenses. Fascinatingly, however, Martin points out that female defendants enjoyed more leniency in convictions and sentencing than did male defendants. The source for this leniency, compassion, and—as Martin terms it—equity for murderesses is the subject of the remaining four chapters.

3> Chapter 2 focuses on crime stories that encouraged (or, at least, allowed for) equitable interpretations of female homicides by reporting on single crimes from multiple points of view and/or by presenting the facts of a case in a way that required active reader interpretation. One such crime narrative involved the case of Elizabeth Abbot, who was executed in 1608 for allegedly killing her employer, Mrs. Killingworth, burning the body, and fleeing the area. In his analysis of Abbot’s news story, Martin calls to light a variety of interpretations that could have emerged from a single report. Abbot’s case could be read as “a story of irredeemable wickedness ultimately brought to light by wonderfully timed acts of providence; of inner fortitude pointing to doubts about her actual guilt (for the crime itself); of absent material evidence linking her to the murder, to which the desperately impromptu re-trial in Cree Church drew attention; or of taxed but justified civil and judicial authorities” (46-7). As Martin demonstrates in this and many other crime reports, readers could, for the first time, begin to interpret news of female homicide in various ways, critically weigh circumstantial evidence on their own, and seize on narrative ambiguities to form their own judgments of female offenders. Often, these judgments differed from the official verdicts leveled on female offenders from the court.

4> In Chapter 3, Martin turns his attention to gallows speeches, confessions, and conversion narratives revolving around convicted murderesses. Martin argues that these narratives, written by prison “visitors” (clergymen who were employed to convert prisoners and extract confessions), encouraged equitable views of convicted women in unique, if subtle, ways. At times, these narratives betrayed the fact that the convicted woman was coerced or blackmailed into confessing (as in Henry Goodcole’s Heavens Speedie Hue and Cry); elsewhere, these texts hinted that an official verdict against a murderess was based on contradictory evidence (as in John Newton’s The Penitent Recognition of Joseph’s Brethren), and it was not uncommon for prison visitors to admit that they extracted confessions only after “some suggestions of pardon” (as was the case in the anonymous Horrid News from St. Martins [105]). In these ways, narratives of confession and conversion opened up spaces for readers to question the guilt of convicted women, to debate the justness of official verdicts, and even to sympathize with female offenders who were otherwise dismissed as wicked or demonic.

5> Chapter 4 focuses on female homicides revolving around poison, a means of killing that was considered exceptionally immoral, since poison was associated with betrayal and its use required premeditation. Poisoning was also popularly associated with female agents and male victims, and as a result this crime was linked conceptually to power imbalances. At times, poisoning was even seen as an act of desperation, performed by victimized women on the men who serially abused them. As Martin puts it, “poison represented a unique opportunity for wives or servants under physical and legal authority to correct perceived abuses of power or debilitating dependency. The economic and class imbalances of such cases opened women’s motives to equitable dispute among neighbors and friends of defendants, and subsequently readers, even if the law disallowed accused or convicted women any formal means of mitigation” (132).

6> The fifth and final chapter deals with women accused and convicted of infanticide. While many news reports on child murder painted such murderesses as unambiguously monstrous figures (often as religious or political allegories), others opened up spaces for more equitable interpretations. An example of the latter can be found in Goodcole’s Natures Cruell Step-Dames, which recounts the case of Elizabeth Barnes, a woman who allegedly murdered her young daughter. Although Goodcole (like many of his contemporaries) figures his murderess as a fallen Eve figure early in the narrative, he also explains Barnes’ desperation in killing her child through the fact that she had been made pregnant, made poor, and finally abandoned by her lover, Richard Evans. As Martin points out, Goodcole’s naming of Barnes’ blameworthy lover is significant and unprecedented: “By shifting responsibility for Barnes’s behavior partly on to a disordered male offender, Goodcole re-imagined the female criminal subject not simply as an autonomous victim of her own moral weakness, but constrained by hostile social agencies” (174). In this news report and many others discussed in Women, Murder, and Equity, Martin impressively exposes the opportunities for equitable interpretations of murderesses in texts that appear unmitigating and unsympathetic on the surface.

7> Martin’s study is remarkable for several reasons. First, the book’s diachronic methodology, based on 123 crime news reports over the course of 124 years, generates a comprehensive analysis of its subject—an analysis that acknowledges the complexity of representations of female homicide, and that calls to light the slow and unsteady emergence of equitable interpretations over time. Second, Martin’s scholarship is truly interdisciplinary in nature, balancing astute literary interpretation and close reading with rigorous (quantitative and qualitative) historical research at every turn. Third, in focusing on the years between 1573 and 1697, Martin not only covers a large and unwieldy span of time carefully and adeptly, but he also bridges Early Modern studies with Restoration studies, something that is often avoided in studies of print culture as well as crime studies.

8> Any work of this magnitude also brings with it minor shortcomings and errors. The book contains a surprising number of typos, as can be seen on pages 15, 24, 47, 55, 64, 88, 101, 142, 162, 167—to name some of the more glaring examples. Also, Martin erroneously classifies the sexual violation of Mary Hobry by her husband as “legally” a rape (71). Martin does not acknowledge that nonconsensual sex between husbands and wives was not defined as “rape” according to British law until 1991.  As the famous jurist Sir Matthew Hale would later reflect in his History of the Pleas of the Crown (1736), “the husband cannot be guilty of a rape committed by himself upon his lawful wife, for by their mutual matrimonial consent and contract the wife hath given up herself in this kind unto her husband, which she cannot retract.” Perhaps more conspicuous is the lack of discussion as to why news sources began to represent female homicides in more complex, critical, and sympathetic ways during this era. While Martin offers several quite reasonable explanations, including increased news coverage, the multiplicity of news genres, ever increasing publisher competition, and emerging faith and interest in empirical evidence, he devotes little discussion to each of these specific causes. All the same, Martin’s study is thorough, original, and groundbreaking. No doubt, his book stands on its own as a valuable piece of scholarship on both the emerging and changing forms Early Modern printed news and on perceptions of female transgressors at this time. Scholars will find, in Women, Murder, and Equity, an invaluable source for further research on female homicide in Early Modern news reports.
_____

Anne Greenfield is an Assistant Professor of English at Valdosta State University, and she is a member of the Editorial Board of Appositions: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature and Culture and Aphra Behn Online: Interactive Journal for Women in the Arts 1640-1830. She has published articles on Restoration / eighteenth-century drama and Aphra Behn, and her current research focuses on depictions of sexual violence in drama from 1660 to 1720.
_____
 
APPOSITIONS:
Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern
Literature & Culture,
ISSN: 1946-1992,
Volume Four (2011): Texts & Contexts
_____

Sunday, May 30, 2010

VOLUME THREE (2010): DIGITAL ARCHIVES

A
PP
OS
IT
IO
NS

http://appositions.blogspot.com/
ISSN: 1946-1992

Volume Three (2010):
Digital Archives & the Field of Production


In Volume Three of APPOSITIONS: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature & Culture, you will find:

* 5 Articles
* 5 Book Reviews

One of those articles first appeared as a conference paper during our 2010 Appositions e-conference. For the closing remarks from that event, please visit this page:
http://appositions.blogspot.com/2010/02/welcome-message.html.

Presenters at our annual e-conference are invited to submit article-length versions of their papers for our standard peer-review process at the journal while we review manuscripts during our submission period, October through April. Conference presentation does not guarantee journal publication, but we do hope that our electronic forum may generate useful commentary on works-in-progress.

The rest of the documents gathered and published here were submitted independently of the 2010 e-conference.
_____

APPOSITIONS: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature & Culture

http://appositions.blogspot.com/
ISSN: 1946-1992

Volume Three (2010):
Digital Archives & the Field of Production

ARTICLES

Elizabeth Scott-Baumann & Ben Burton,
Encoding Form: A proposed database of poetic form

Dorothea Heitsch,
Renaissance Soul-Searching (1555-1584):
Maurice Scève, Jacques Peletier du Mans, Pierre de Ronsard, Guillaume Du Bartas, René Bretonnayau


Colleen E. Kennedy,
“Do You Smell a Fault?”:
Detecting and Deodorizing King Lear’s Distinctly Feminine Odor

George Klawitter,
Andrew Marvell’s Use of John Donne: “The Definition of Love”

Andrew Russ,
Four Diseases of Social Speech in “Hamlet”

REVIEWS

Claire Bordelon, reviewing:
John Bowes, Richard Brathwait: The First Lakeland Poet. Hugill Publications (2007).

Elizabeth H. Hageman, reviewing:
Ann Hollinshead Hurley and Chanita Goodblatt, eds., Women Editing/Editing Women: Early Modern Women Writers and the New Textualism. Cambridge Scholars Publishing (2009).

Sheri L. McCord, reviewing:
Rebecca Laroche, Medical Authority and Englishwomen’s Herbal Texts, 1550-1650. Ashgate Publishing (2009).

Kathryn Vomero Santos, reviewing:
Amy Greenstadt, Rape and the Rise of the Author: Gendering Intention in Early Modern England. Ashgate Publishing (2009).

Adam Swann, reviewing:
Nicholas McDowell and Nigel Smith, eds., The Oxford Handbook of Milton. Oxford University Press (2009).
_____

In our opinion, we have assembled a robust gathering of works that all strike a vital balance between traditional and innovative concerns in the field. The content speaks/reads for itself, but, of course, we also welcome your participation.

Appositions is designed for commentary and open-access. You may post your questions and comments via the “post a comment” link at the bottom of each document page.

We hope you enjoy your visit, and that you’ll share Appositions with your colleagues, friends, and students.

—The Editors
_____

APPOSITIONS: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature & Culture, http://appositions.blogspot.com/, ISSN: 1946-1992, Volume Three (2010): Digital Archives

* * * ARTICLES * * *

E. Scott-Baumann & B. Burton: "Encoding Form"

Elizabeth Scott-Baumann & Ben Burton
Oxford University

Encoding Form: A proposed database of poetic form

1> In 1979, Heather Dubrow called for a new methodology in early modern studies. ‘We are still prone to separate literary history and generic analysis,’ she observed, ‘[b]ut the two modes of criticism can illuminate each other

“exploring why certain genres flourished when they did and how they shaped and were shaped by the temper of their age is one of the surest ways of tracing the complicated movements that inform literary history.”[1]

Thirty years later, it seems that literary scholars have been slow to respond to Dubrow’s appeal for a new kind of historical formalism, especially when developing electronic resources.[2] To be sure, the last four decades have seen exciting developments in digital literary studies, including e-texts and online corpora; multimedia electronic editions; full-text resources for biography, bibliography, and lexicography; as well as computer-assisted textual analysis. In the field of early modern studies, online resources such as Early English Books Online (EEBO), Chadwyck Healey’s Literature Online (LION), and Gale Cengage’s Eighteenth Century Collections Online (EECO) have enabled scholars and students to conduct literary historical research in novel ways, allowing users to discover obscure publications and pursue new lines of enquiry through keyword-searchable full texts.[3] Such resources as these have transformed the way we study words and phrases, but they are not designed to support sophisticated analysis of the formal properties of early modern texts. As scholars begin to reassess the relationship between formal and historical study, we need electronic resources that will enable scholars and students to study form in a historically-rooted way, stimulating new questions about parallels and differences across literary periods.

2> What might such a resource look like? This paper explores the motivations and challenges of creating a database of form for early modern English poetry. We are currently planning a database that will contain information on the genres, metrical structures and rhyme schemes of all poetry in early modern printed texts. Users will be able to search a variety of criteria, exploring specific poetic forms by name, or metre, or rhyme scheme and then refine search results within a time period, or according to author, or place of publication, or language. They would also be able to enter information about the formal properties of a poem, such as its rhyme scheme, and be able to view similar or identical forms in the database. The database would change the study of poetic form in the way that LION, EEBO and other keyword-searchable full text corpora have revolutionized our ability to study imitation, influence and tradition at the thematic and content level of words. In this paper we will outline the kinds of data this resource could provide, and the kinds of questions we would want to ask of it.

Purpose and Objectives

3> This database will contribute to an ongoing effort to combine literary history with the study of prosody and genre. In doing so, we hope to reassess the scope and purpose of prosodic analysis, and its relation to electronic resources, in shaping our understanding of the early modern period. The database would in no way replace scholarly analysis, but it can assist us in certain aspects of prosodic study, and will open up new areas for teaching and research.

4> The primary objective of the database is to provide an unprecedented quantity of information about poetic form – such as syllable count, rhyme scheme and rhyme words – which form the basis of prosodic and generic analysis. It does not aim to offer definitive or exhaustive analyses, but to stimulate further enquiry and to provide data for independent analysis. The database assists prosodic study by dramatically reducing the time taken to perform basic metrical analysis such as counting syllables and identifying rhyme schemes. More excitingly, it opens up areas of enquiry by enabling scholars to ask new questions about literary texts. At present, prosodic analysis is usually confined to isolated studies of an individual author or small groups of authors. One of the ultimate objectives of the database is to broaden the scope of prosodic analysis by providing the raw materials for a cultural history of poetic form and generic change across the early modern period. In this sense, the database will enable scholars to ask the same kinds of questions about form that our current resources allow us to ask about words, for example: What is the origin (or origins) of a given form? How does its structure, use and meaning change over time? Are there variations in use and meaning in different regions, or among different groups? How does a given form relate to others, and how does this relationship change over time? To pursue the analogy with lexical analysis, the database invites us to explore what might be called the etymology and morphology of poetic form, as well as the complex history of prosodic dialects, sociolects and idiolects.

Methodology

5> The database would encode additional information about the generic and formal characteristics of texts in our existing online corpora of early modern texts. At present, resources such as EEBO are designed as digital libraries and, as such, are not concerned with adding value by annotating the texts they compile.[4] Our strategy is to create an interface that would interrogate marked-up texts, as users present queries, so that the user’s search would call up certain poems and records of these poems’ formal features. Users would be able to see a short, searchable record of formal features for each text but also to search much more widely and narrowly according to their own research interests. We propose to annotate existing texts created by the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership (EEBO-TCP), enriching these texts by providing detailed information about their prosodic structure. We would use a Text Encoding Initiative (TEI) P5-compliant scheme to enrich the relevant encoded EEBO-TCP texts.[5] The TEI already provides a base tag set for encoding verse, including stanza divisions, caesurae, enjambment, rhyme scheme and metrical information, as well as a special purpose rhyme element to support the simple analysis of rhyming words. For rhyme and metrical analysis, the module for verse includes attributes that allow users to specify encoding for the conventional metrical structure of the element, as well as for the actual realization of the conventional metrical structure applicable to a given element of a text.[6]

6> What kind of information might be marked-up in this way? As David Chisholm and David Robey point out, ‘[t]here is...a general question as to whether text markup for scholarly interchange should be limited to broad formal conventions (e.g. meter, rhyme, stanzaic forms), or whether individual characteristics of verse texts may also be included (a step that often represents the foundation of a stylistic interpretation).’[7] What is more, since prosodic analysis necessarily entails an element of critical judgement, any encoder will need to formulate clear principles for marking up verse. For example, can we always distinguish between formal conventions and individual characteristics of verse? How should we indicate that the pattern indicated by our mark up is not the only possible pattern for the verse text under consideration?

7> We believe that some of these questions are best approached through practice. In our pilot project outlined below, we will test both methods of encoding on a sample of texts spanning a range of genres from the 1590s, including sonnet sequences, epic poetry and drama. At present, we can only speculate as to which approach will be most appropriate for a project of this scope. We suspect, however, that a simple mark-up of rhyme scheme and conventional metrical structure will provide more information about texts that involve a variety of stanzaic patterns – such as sonnet sequences, or collections of lyric poetry – than texts that use a single stanza, such as epic poems, or those which rely heavily on a single conventional metrical structure, like drama. If this is true, it seems likely that the project will need to provide information about formal conventions as well as a limited range of individual characteristics. Of course, this would be labour intensive. Manually marking up the actual metrical structure of poetic texts at line level could prove extremely cumbersome and time consuming. One possibility is that the database might develop in phases, beginning with rhyme scheme and conventional metrical structure, and then progressing to include further information about the actual features of these texts. This approach allows the flexibility to encode additional layers of complexity. These could include highlighting irregularities in rhyme scheme, or indicating any deviation in the real metrical structure of a line from the pattern defined by the conventional metrical structure.
In the Pilot Project section (below) we discuss the possibilities of this kind of mark up, as well as its limitations in relation to our pilot project.

8> This pragmatic approach can only take us so far, however, as we attempt to address larger theoretical questions about how we mark-up verse texts. In a future article we will examine the theoretical assumptions that lie behind the TEI guidelines for encoding verse, and will situate our database in relation to recent historical studies of early modern prosody.[8] At this early stage, we can only highlight some of the large problems that remain to be answered by our project. For example, is the purpose of the database to examine poetry in the terms that early modern poets may have used, or to provide an analytical framework that draws on current prosodic theory? The former approach would allow users to see the period in something like its own terms, but it is open to criticism from theoretical prosodists who distinguish between ‘the conscious metrical principles to which poets may have adhered’ and ‘the principles which actually governed their practice.’[9] This is an important distinction, but it leaves us wondering how these ‘principles’ are to be defined in light of the ongoing methodological conflicts in verse studies. As Richard Cureton observes, ‘the failure of theoretical prosodists in [the twentieth] century to develop a generally accepted method of rhythmical analysis has made it impossible for literary historians and historically minded prosodists to take advantage of these advances in any coherent way.’[10]

9> These methodological questions are complicated further by practical and pedagogical concerns: should we adopt a traditional accentual-syllabic method of scansion that is already used in many textbooks and prosodic manuals, or should we eschew this arguably outdated system in favour of a more credible but less familiar method of analysis? A possible solution to this problem, adopted by Thomas Carper and Derek Attridge, is to combine modern methods of scansion and traditional terminology (such as ‘iambic pentameter’ and ‘trochaic trimeter’), with the proviso that these terms provide a ‘useful shorthand for describing particular sorts of meters’ rather than ‘keys to what’s really going on in metrical lines.’[11] This solution may be pragmatic, but it might also be seen as theoretically suspect. As Peter Groves argues, ‘the traditional description [of verse texts] lacks intellectual coherence and rigour, and should not be perpetuated merely by inertia, incumbency, habit or apathy.’[12] While we admire Groves’s refusal to compromise on this point, we hope to establish principles for encoding verse texts which address the concerns of theoretical prosodists as well as scholars, teachers, students and non-specialists who are already familiar with traditional methods of analysing poetic form.

Dissemination and Publication

10> Online databases and editions are now a central part of UK and US universities’ research resources. Oxford University, where we work as lecturers and researchers, currently subscribes to resources with a variety of search functions and searchability, such as The Bible in English (searchable by key word, or chapter and verse), the Poetry Archive and Past Masters (largely philosophical texts). Reference works are also increasingly used in their online forms. The Oxford English Dictionary and the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography are now largely used online in frequently updated and carefully managed versions, and scholarly journals increasingly make their articles accessible through JStor.org and Project MUSE.

11> Many databases providing primary texts, such as LION, EEBO and ECCO, are now commonly subscribed to by universities and widely used by undergraduates, postgraduates and senior scholars. These existing databases offer a sweep of literature from medieval to twentieth-century, and some provide both digital facsimiles and full-text versions of rare (and common) books. Digital facsimiles have enabled thousands of students and scholars to study rare, fragile books as they were originally published, including manuscript drafts (see Oxford’s First World War Poetry Digital Archive) and manuscript texts (the JISC-funded Digitizing Correspondence project under way at London’s Centre for Editing Lives and Letters; the Perdita Project providing facsimiles of early modern women’s writings). Full-text versions of swathes of poetry have been used for stylometric analysis to help ascertain authorship or date a work in a writer’s life or used to trace allusion, echoes and imitations of other authors (just as the availability of scholarship online has enabled many universities to use plagiarism software such as Turnitin to screen their undergraduates’ work).

12> The Text Creation Partnership provides texts to Chadwyck-Healey, who mount them online through their (otherwise facsimile-and-bibliographic-record only) EEBO database. EEBO therefore provides access to both facsimiles and an increasing number of full-text transcriptions of early printed books. We are keen to work with EEBO-TCP texts for the early modern phase of the database, using text encoding techniques to create enriched texts from which the searchable interface will glean and exhibit data on formal aspects of all poetry. We aim to negotiate with EEBO and Chadwyck-Healey to find a form of publication that both respects intellectual property and commercial interests, while also making this rich new material accessible to the widest possible audience.

13> At the current stage of planning we are considering several options for the dissemination of our research findings and the publication of the database. These include 1. An open access interface available to any internet user that provides both a searchable interface and access to marked up texts; 2. Access to searchable interface and marked-up texts to EEBO-TCP subscribing institutions, perhaps as one of the partners’ custom interfaces; 3. Open access to database and texts but not with mark up. This would mean that if we are not able to make the XML-encoded texts freely available, we would display the texts in their entirety (as users request them), but with the encoding invisible. The interface would interpret our encoding and display the verse with, for example, its stresses marked with accents, or its rhyme scheme colour-coded, rather than with visible tags; 4. Open access to database but no texts. We are most keen on the first option, but this will depend on how our negotiations with EEBO-TCP and Chadwyck-Healey progress. Option 3 would have obvious benefits over Option 4 in that institutions who do not subscribe to EEBO such as schools, where we are keen to see the database used in teaching, would have access to the texts as well as our data, just without the mark up visible.

14> This project would result in a sustainable resource that could be developed beyond the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries across every period, and could be connected to huge existing databases of poetry already subscribed to by universities, and ideally also be available to school students across the UK and USA.

Applications: Research and Teaching

15> We are currently in an exciting period of literary criticism, as scholars review the formal, political, theoretical and historical approaches of the previous century and call for perspectives that unite formalist literary and historical analysis.[13] Their work questions the critical tendency to conflate certain poetic genres such as lyric with outmoded critical methodologies of the early twentieth century, and encourages us to rethink the longstanding association between generic analysis and a rarefied concept of the aesthetic. Eschewing the New Critical ideal of formal unity or coherence, these scholars propose a freshly theorized ‘historical formalism,’ reassessing poetic form as historically specific, historically determined, and historically efficacious.

16> There has already been some excellent work in this field, concerned with the rise and fall of genres, changes in prosodic tastes and practices, how writers distinguished and differentiated the specific functions of literary texts, as well as a history of aesthetics, all of which have been sidelined by a cultural studies movement which has dominated literary scholarship in recent years.[14] At present, however, the scope of this research is restricted by the lack of electronic resources that would make prosodic information of all sorts more easily accessed, more quickly searched, and more widely shared. Indeed, we would imagine that many scholars interested in historical formalism are currently wrestling with the same kind of problems that frustrated a previous generation of scholars working on vocabulary and verbal allusion. As a result, scholars interested in formal and historical analysis have understandably tended to focus their energies on analysing a limited sample of texts or a small group of authors. Larger studies, spanning a broad time period and a wide range of authors, are often richly suggestive and point the way towards future research, but scholars need new resources to provide the kinds of evidence that could support these ambitious projects.

17> In creating an electronic database of poetic form for the early modern period, we would seek to provide a crucial tool in this emergent field, enabling scholars to explore the unpredictable, multiple interactions between form and history, while stimulating new questions about the cultural significance of specific forms as well as how particular genres changed and developed over time.

18> The multiple research implications of this database would change the way in which scholarship on poetic form is conducted. Scholars will be able to make new connections between authors of different periods, styles and cultural identities. For example, they would be able to trace the progress of a particular form, looking at how the heroic couplet was used before its most famous practitioner, Alexander Pope, and after him. It would also be possible to discern how common metrical irregularity was within certain forms, and whether this was dictated by subject matter, education or gender. Scholars would also be able to identify heterogeneity within certain forms, for instance, exploring how much formal variation existed within the sonnet boom of the 1590s, which variants endured into the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and which were abandoned but received a later revival.

19> Finding a poem difficult to categorise, it would be possible to use the database to investigate similar forms, exploring possible models and traditions, or revealing valuable innovations in form. Rhyme words would also be detailed in the database, providing rich new evidence of how rhyme could function: Were certain rhyme words always used for comic effect? Do particular rhymes appear more frequently in certain periods than others, and what might this reveal about the cultural significance of rhyme at these moments? It was a commonplace of the New Criticism of the earlier twentieth century that, in Pope’s words, ‘The Sound must seem an Eccho to the Sense’[15]; our resource would aim to provide the largest amount of data with which to explore the myriad aesthetic and political ramifications of this principle.

20> The Electronic Database of Poetic Form would also be an immensely useful teaching tool, at both school and university level. Recent research has confirmed that online resources such as EEBO are already transforming undergraduate teaching and learning.[16] Electronic resources are used by undergraduates more than any other group and our database would draw on enthusiasm for online material to challenge and develop their reading of poetry. Undergraduate students might be able to submit entries of rhyme schemes and syllable counts on a connected pedagogical website, developing their own skills at identifying certain metrical forms and exploring the implications of rhyme words and different kinds of rhyme.

21> In the same way, the database could be used to teach secondary school students about rhyme and metre, providing an accessible, hands-on introduction to key concepts of prosodic analysis, and enabling them to explore the variety of poetic forms used by a particular author. Students might be able to highlight and annotate specific features of their chosen texts, following online exercises organized by a teacher, and submitting work for further discussion in an electronic forum with class members. Here we find a particularly strong warrant for making our resource freely available to any internet user, especially to institutions which cannot afford the subscription fees which accompany many electronic resources in the humanities. Although we are currently considering several options for the publication of our database, we have been encouraged by the recent development of open access resources, such as the new Shakespeare Quartos Archive (http://www.quartos.org/), that are freely available for sophisticated, close analysis of literary texts for students and scholars across the globe.[17] The success of this resource convinces us that online resources can satisfy the demands of the scholarly community as well as the wider public. In our pilot project, described below, we will experiment with an interface that will be accessible to non-specialists while also providing complex search features for more advanced users.

Pilot Project: 1590s

22> The pilot project comprises two stages: 1. A small database containing information on the metrical structures and rhyme schemes of all verse in the first edition of 10 texts published between 1590 and 1599. 2. A larger database containing information on the metrical structures and rhyme schemes of all verse in first editions of texts published during this period.

23> The first stage of the pilot will illustrate the variety of texts contained in this database, ranging from those written entirely or predominantly in verse (such as epic poems, verse drama and sonnet collections), to those which include poetry and prose in varying proportions. The two principal investigators will work on the initial project, and the results of this work will help determine the search functions of the database, as well as the timescale and the resources needed for the second stage of the pilot. The second stage will demonstrate the complete search functions of the database across a sample period. We aim to provide information about poetry in first editions published between 1590 and 1599, ranging from works written entirely in verse, to brief quotations and epigrams that feature in larger works.

24> The 1590s was a unique and exciting decade in the development of poetry in English, with poets experimenting with classical metres, forging and theorising a vernacular literary tradition, reflecting continental influences, as well as the inflections of music and rhetoric. It saw the publication of Sidney’s Defence of Poesie, one of the most influential formulations of the purpose and responsibilities of poetry, as well as his sonnet sequence Astrophel and Stella. The decade saw the publication of Spenser’s major English epic, The Faerie Queene, Marlowe’s Ovidian Hero and Leander and Shakespeare’s two great narrative poems, Venus and Adonis and Lucrece. These latter two have been characterised as the most patterned, structured and even the most ‘literary’ of all Shakespeare’s works.[18] Heather Dubrow has talked of modern readers’ ‘distrust of elaborate devices’ and though these poems are widely studied, much remains to be explored in their formal patterns and innovations.[19] These poems enjoyed a much greater fame in Shakespeare’s lifetime than they do now, and it was these works that motivated contemporaries to write about the honeyed softness of Shakespeare’s verse. Our database would allow further exploration of what exactly such critical terms meant in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Were these works defined by their formal regularity, by enjambment creating an admired sense of flow, or can we see ways in which irregularity and shifts in metre might also be admired? These terms of smoothness and softness became connected with the couplet in the eighteenth century and it would be fascinating to be able ultimately to compare the couplets of the sixteenth century with those of the eighteenth. Did poets’ use of the couplet become more uniform as it gained dominance?[20] Shakespeare’s narrative poems of course do not employ couplets, but for Venus and Adonis iambic pentameter sestets (rhyming ababcc) and for Lucrece rhyme royal (7 pentameter lines rhyming ababbcc). The Electronic Database of Poetic Form would allow users to input these schemes (either metre, rhyme scheme or both) and immediately see what other works were published in the period using the same stanzas, whether these became more or less common after Shakespeare’s poems were published, whether these forms were used for comic, tragic or other material, amongst numerous other research questions.

25> The 1590s also saw the rise of some of the greatest works in English verse drama, which this database will include, such as Marlowe’s Tamburlaine, Dido Queen of Carthage and Edward II, and Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, Titus Andronicus, Richard II and Love’s Labour’s Lost. It has often been said that late sixteenth-century drama and poetry influenced each other, and this database would provide illuminating evidence of the exact nature of this influence. Certainly Love’s Labour’s Lost includes poetry which alludes to song forms such as madrigal verse, as well as strophic forms, and is the most heavily rhymed of Shakespeare’s plays. The rhymes are often semantically significant, such as the repeated pairings of ‘lord’ and ‘word,’ ‘eyes’ and ‘lies’. These rhymes were indexed in Helge Kökeritz’s Shakespeare’s Pronunciation of 1953, which used linguistic features such as rhyme words and puns as evidence of pronunciation. Our database will shed light on this issue by providing a far greater set of data on rhymes across first the 1590s and then the early modern period. It might also tackle and challenge in its methodology some of the assumptions that have been made about pronunciation on the basis of rhyme. As we develop the database, looking to ascertain which words constitute rhyming pairs, we will need to examine works on early modern pronunciation, but as these works have often used literary texts as their evidence, we face a thorny but fascinating methodological challenge in deciding the extent to which seeming rhymes can act as evidence of actual pronunciation.

26> The songs and sonnets in Sidney’s Astrophel and Stella constitute one of the most varied and sophisticated poetic sequences ever written, and were a major influence on the dazzling metrical and rhyme forms of the Sidney psalms. Much has been written about Astrophel and Stella as a political and social text, as well as about its Petrarchanism, anti-Petrarchanism and its playful manipulations of courtly lyric conventions. The sonnets indeed register tensions and competing impulses, between political activity and alienation, desire and frustration, authority and submission, the wishes of the individual and the rules of society. A database recording the structural rhyme and metre, rhyme words, and ideally the moments of irregularity in these poems would allow a far more nuanced analysis of whether these tensions and energies are embodied in the poems’ forms in ways that a reading of individual poems, or even reading all the poems in sequence, might not reveal.

27> The 1590s saw very few women publishing their works, or at least publishing under their own names. The translation of Robert Garnier’s Marc Antoine by Lady Mary Sidney Herbert, Countess of Pembroke, is a notable and fascinating exception. The Countess of Pembroke’s Antonius reveals her characteristic formal sophistication. Garnier’s drama was written more for reading or domestic performance than for public productions, and Antonius’ popularity (editions in 1592 and 1595) might be due to its suitability to informal performance.[21] Antonius marks an interesting point in English drama, as Pembroke adapts Senecan drama from a French work in alexandrines, to her own combination of blank verse (only in the 1590s becoming the dominant form for drama) with metrically diverse rhymed choruses. The excellent recent editions of the Countess of Pembroke’s works alert readers to the formal variety of the Countess’ works, but our database would allow her innovations to be studied in much greater detail and with greater scope in the context of her contemporaries.[22] The influence of Antonius on Shakespeare’s Antony and Cleopatra has been noted, but much remains to be explored in terms of the influence of translated drama, of drama by women and of the emergence of blank verse drama, and by allowing synchronic and diachronic comparisons of large texts our database would provide unprecedented quantity and quality of data from which to build such analyses.[23]

28> The nature of poetry in the 1590s also demands that we consider including works circulated in manuscript as well as those published in print. The Sidney Psalter, a series of 150 psalms composed by Philip Sidney and Mary Sidney Herbert, Countess of Pembroke, was famously praised by John Donne as ‘the highest matter in the noblest form.’[24] It was never published in the early modern period, and yet it was as highly esteemed and as influential as any printed work. If our database were able to include such a work, it would make it possible to ask new questions as well as to investigate current scholarly claims with an unprecedented data set. Fascinating work has been done on how both the Sidneys’ psalm translations were influenced by the forms of Sidney’s Astrophel and Stella, but the database would allow us to ask far broader questions about how manuscript poetry and print poetry cross-fertilised, how the psalter influenced its readers in their own writing, how the psalms compare formally to other works by both Philip and Mary Sidney. There are many reasons to include a work such as the Sidneys’ psalms in our database, not least its technical audacity and influence, but some of these qualities also make it a test-case for the difficulties of expanding our remit from first editions of printed works to manuscripts. The question of authorship for the psalter has largely been resolved, with the first forty-three psalms written by Philip Sidney and then revised by his sister, and the rest of the psalms her work alone. The case is not so clear for many manuscript works, where the form of publication and circulation itself led to a more flexible, collaborative process of writing and reading. This would pose questions for the database in terms of how to categorise authorship, possibly with levels of certainty indicated. While these questions are of course pertinent to printed texts, existing databases such as EEBO provide a fairly authoritative precedent for attribution. The question of dating is similarly vexed with manuscript texts. Perhaps most difficult would be the question of what to include. We would need access to full-text transcriptions of manuscript poetry that are being created currently in an active but dispersed field. We would need to address the possibility of working with a confined field, at least initially. This might mean starting with the poetry in manuscripts in one particular institution, for instance the Bodleian or British Library, or working on the texts included in a particular catalogue, such as Peter Beal’s Index of Literary Manuscripts.[25]

Conclusion

29> The digitization of books and archives has both stimulated exciting new scholarship and provoked concern that the digital image has lost many of the attributes and features of the printed page that make it a work uniquely of its period. This electronic database of poetic form would build on existing digitization to create new ways of thinking about poetry both in its moment of production and far beyond it. Each poem, whether lyric, epic, song, verse drama, will be open to analysis both for its own formal features, whether common or unique, and also in the context of its year, decade or century. We hope that this database will provide a framework in which scholars can find unprecedented ways of answering their research questions and, crucially, a tool that will provoke them to ask new questions.

Notes:

1. Heather Dubrow, ‘The Country House Poem: A Study in Generic Development,’ Genre, 12 (1979), 153-79 (p. 159).

2. For further discussion of these issues, excluding electronic resources, see Dubrow, ‘The Politics of Aesthetics: Recuperating Formalism and the Country House Poem. in Renaissance Literature and its Formal Engagements, ed. by Mark David Rasmussen (New York; Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2002), pp. 67-88.

3. For an introduction to these resources in early moderns studies, see Matthew Steggle, ‘“Knowledge will be multiplied”: Digital Literary Studies and Early Modern Literature’ in A Companion to Digital Literary Studies, ed. by Ray Siemens and Susan Schreibman (Oxford: Blackwell, 2007), pp. 82-105.

4. Steggle (2007), pp. 82-105, (p. 88). For further discussion of this aspect of humanities computing projects, see Susan Schreibman, ‘Computer-mediated Texts and Textuality: Theory and Practice,’ Computers and the Humanities, 36 (2002), 283-293.

5. By ‘P5-compliant,’ we mean that our database will follow the latest version (‘P5’) of the TEI Guidelines for Electronic Text Encoding and Interchange. The guidelines define and document a markup language for representing the structural, renditional and conceptual features of texts. An online version of the P5 guidelines is available at http://www.tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/,
[accessed 26 April 2010].

6. P5: Guidelines for Electronic Text Encoding and Interchange.

7. David Chisholm and David Robey, ‘Encoding Verse Texts,’ Computers and the Humanities, 29 (1995), 99-111 (pp. 108-109); reprinted in Text Encoding Initiative: Background and Context, ed. by Nancy Ide and Jean Véronis (Dodrecht; London: Kluwer Academic, 1995), pp. 99-102.

8. Ben Burton and Elizabeth Scott-Baumann, ‘The Problem of Prosodic History: Towards an Electronic Database of Poetic Form’ (in progress).

9. Derek Attridge, The Rhythms of English Poetry (London: Longman, 1982), p. 147. Historical studies of early modern prosody tend to follow traditional methods of scansion. See, for example, Susan Woods, Natural Emphasis: English Versification from Chaucer to Dryden (San Marino, CA: Huntington Library, 1984); O. B. Hardison, Prosody and Purpose in the English Renaissance (Baltimore and London: John Hopkins University Press, 1989).

10. Richard D. Cureton, Rhythmic Phrasing in English Verse (London: Longman, 1992), p. 429.

11. Thomas Carper and Derek Attridge, Meter and Meaning: An Introduction to Rhythm in Poetry (London: Routledge, 2003), p. 87.

12. Peter L. Groves, Strange Music: The Meter of the English Heroic Line (Victoria, B. C.: English Literary Studies, University of Victoria, 1998), p. 33.

13. For a useful introduction, see Mark David Rasmussen, ‘Introduction: New Formalisms?’ in Rasmussen ed. (2002), pp. 1-16. On the shifting fortunes of formalism in literary studies, and for a lively defence of its continued importance to literary scholarship, see Richard Strier, Resistant Structures: Particularity, Radicalism, and Renaissance Texts (Berkeley and Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press, 1995).

14. For an overview of current work in this field, see the essays collected in Shakespeare and Historical Formalism, ed. by Stephen Cohen (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2007), as well as in Reading for Form, ed. by Susan J. Wolfson and Marshall Brown (London: University of Washington Press, 2006), originally published as a special issue, Modern Language Quarterly 61:1 (2000).

15. ‘An Essay on Criticism’, l. 365 in The Twickenham Edition of the Poems of Alexander Pope, gen. ed. John Butt, 11 vols (London: Methuen, 1938-1968) I, p. 281.

16. On the uses of EEBO in particular, see Thea Lindquist and Heather Wicht, ‘Pleas’d By a Newe Inuention?: Assessing the Impact of Early English Books Online on Teaching and Research at the University of Colorado at Boulder,’ The Journal of Academic Librarianship, 33:3 (2007), 347-60.

17. Louise Tickle, ‘Shakespeare goes Digital,’ The Guardian, Tuesday 26 January 2010.
[Accessed 1 February 2010].

18. See, for instance, the introduction to Shakespeare’s Poems, ed. by Katherine Duncan-Jones and H. R. Woudhuysen (London: Arden Shakespeare, 2007).

19. Heather Dubrow, Captive Victors: Shakespeare’s Narrative Poems and Sonnets (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1987), p. 16; see also, looking at numeric patterning rather than form, Christopher Butler and Alastair Fowler, ‘Time-beguiling sport: Number Symbolism in Shakespeare’s Venus and Adonis,’ in Venus and Adonis: Critical Essays, ed. by Philip C. Kolin (New York: Garland Publishing, 1997), pp. 157-169.

20. Though scholars including J. Paul Hunter have productively questioned many assumptions about the couplet and its hegemony. Hunter, ‘Formalism and History: Binarism and the Anglophone Couplet,’ Modern Language Quarterly, 61 (2000), 109-129.

21. See Selected works of Mary Sidney Herbert Countess of Pembroke, ed. by Margaret P. Hannay, Noel J. Kinnamon, and Michael G. Brennan (Arizona Center for Medieval and Renaissance Studies, Tempe, Arizona, 2005), p. 42.

22. The Collected works of Mary Sidney Herbert Countess of Pembroke, ed. by Margaret P. Hannay, Noel J. Kinnamon, and Michael G. Brennan (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998), 2 vols; Selected Works, ed. by Hannay, Kinnamon, Brennan.

23. Michael Steppat, ‘Shakespeare’s Response to Dramatic Tradition in Antony and Cleopatra’ in Shakespeare- Text, Language, Criticism: Essays in Honour of Marvin Spevack, ed. by Bernard Fabian and Kurt Tetzeli von Rosador (Hildesheim: Olms-Weidmann, 1987), pp. 254-79.

24. ‘Upon the Translation of the Psalms by Sir Philip Sidney, and the Countess of Pembroke His Sister’, l. 11 in The Sidney Psalter: The Psalms of Sir Philip and Mary Sidney, ed. by Hannibal Hamlin and others (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009), p. 3.

25. Peter Beal, Index of Literary Manuscripts, 2 vols (London: Mansell Publishing Ltd, 1987).
_____

Elizabeth Scott-Baumann is a Research Fellow at Wolfson College, Oxford University and a Lecturer in Renaissance Literature at Oxford Brookes University. She has published articles in Literature Compass and Women’s Writing and co-edited The Intellectual Culture of Puritan Women, 1558-1680 (Palgrave Macmillan, forthcoming). She is currently writing a book called Forms of Engagement: Women, Poetry and Culture 1640-1680.

Ben Burton is a lecturer at Oxford University. He has published articles in Renaissance and Reformation / Renaissance et Réforme as well as entries for The Story of the Church in England (forthcoming). He is currently writing a book called Poetics of the Eucharist from Robert Southwell to John Milton.
_____

APPOSITIONS: Studies in Renaissance / Early Modern Literature & Culture, http://appositions.blogspot.com/, ISSN: 1946-1992, Volume Three (2010): Digital Archives